TERMS & CONDITIONS   CARS   TRUCKS   BIKES   CARAVANS   BOATS   MACHINES   BS LINK   MOTORSM.COM
COMPLAINTS CORNER
complaints.motorsm.com
"Complaints Corner" provides an online billboard to publicize problems or complaints about your car or poor after-sales support from dealerships and manufacturers. Good news about exceptional customer service etc. will also be published. N.B. MotorSM is not responsible nor endorse views expressed by contributors.
LATEST POSTING
LOG IN - ADD COMMENTS
AUG 2008 - COMPLAINTS CORNER    7  6  5  4  3  2  1/2008  12  11  10  9  8  7  6  5  4  3  2  1/2007  2006

FORD FAIRLANE  1996:  RE: HEAT NOT DISTRIBUTING/BLEND MOTOR REPLACED     *REPLY*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
HEATING

Hi Ern.
As Mark suggested, if the heater hoses are both very hot to the touch, then the problem must be in the ventilation control. Have you run a self test on the system? (Press button sequence to initiate) Code E2 is a blend door failure. If the blend door motor is functioning there may be an obstruction in the door itself. The self test should show this. Otherwise there may be a failure in the path of the mode system.

Dav... Sorry I replied to a different post with your name.

POSTED BY: L DAVIS - BOMADERRY, NSW - AUS, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"FORD FAIRLANE EL 1996: HEAT NOT DISTRIBUTING/BLEND MOTOR REPLACED - 1996 Fairlane Ghia. Heating problem for 2 years. Tried everything. Ford can't help me. Replaced blend motor, water valve, checked vacuum solenoids. Radiator is not blocked. All vacuum lines are connected. All ACC sensors have been replaced. Relays swapped. Will not deliver hot air. Can hear blend motor operating. Fan is working. ACC showing no faults. No heat comes out. Help!

I love this car and done a lot to it but the heater will make me sell it."
POSTED BY: ERN ATTARD - IPSWICH, QLD, AUS 26 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Grab hold of both the inlet and outlet hoses near the firewall once the engine is warm with the heater turned on. You should feel heat on both hoses. If not, you do not have water flowing through the heater. You have replaced all the common failing areas of the Ford heating system except the heater core which may be blocked. Try flushing it and see how that goes, otherwise you may need to replace it.
Good Luck
Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC 27/8/2008

MITSUBISHI PAJERO  2001:  RE: OVERHEATING TOLD IT IS ECU FAILURE WITH TEMP GAUGE     *REPLY*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
COOLING SYSTEM

If you are not losing any water, then the gauge or sender unit may be the problem. If the vehicle rapidly overheats, it should be throwing out water.

Good Luck
Mark.

POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"MITSUBISHI PAJERO NM 2001: OVERHEATING TOLD IT IS ECU FAILURE WITH TEMP GAUGE - Any advice on the possibility someone else has experienced the rapid increase in temp and then decrease. Could be radiator block but could also be this gauge as the Mitsubishi dealer has advised.

Thanks."
POSTED BY: JAIME PATULLO - BRISBANE , QLD, AUS 30 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I am having a similar problem with my NM Pajero 2000 GLS. From cold after about 10 minutes of running the temperature gauge goes to the hot mark then quickly drops back to the normal temperature. It will then go up and down between normal and hot. I have monitored the head temperature while this is happening and the head temp sits between 75-85C. I would be interested to know if you solved the problem and if so what was the problem?

Regards, Brendan
POSTED BY: BRENDAN - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS 4 OCT 2008

TOYOTA HILUX D4D 2007:  INJECTOR PROBLEMS (RATTLY MOTOR)    *COMPLAINT*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

I have a 2007 D4D SR5 Hilux with 45,000kms on it. It has really loud engine rattle that lasts for around half an hour at first start up then quietens down but you can still hear it whenever you accelerate or de-accelerate. My fuel consumption has also gone up as I'm now only getting around 1000-1100 kms per tank (125lt tank fitted) was getting around 1300km's per tank, the noise appeared at around 30,000km's.

I have taken my ute into Emerald Toyota a few times and they finally said that they noticed the noise on the last trip and "supposedly sent the computer read out down to Brisbane". When they rang after they got what ever information back from Brisbane they said that there was nothing wrong and proceeded to give me a how to drive to conditions booklet (arrogant ****).

Any how I have now been to 2 different mechanical servicing shops in town and 3 in Rockhampton. 4 of the 5 mechanics said that it had an injector problem and fifth one said that they had put new injection systems in 23 D4D motors (Hilux and Prado) in the past 2.5 years. The owner of this business also told me not to hold my breath to get Toyota to fix it until it is out of warranty.

Now with all that said I am presenting my Toyota dealership with 5 independent reports tomorrow morning (01/09/08). If they do nothing I have been speaking to a solicitor and consumer affairs and I'm not going down without a fight.

To everyone else getting shrugged off by their Toyota dealership I suggest go and get a couple of independent reports from other mechanics then present it to Toyota.

POSTED BY: ALEX MITTING - EMERALD, QLD - AUS, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Drop the engine oil and take note of how much there is. If it smells like diesel, too much fuel may be getting pumped into the motor and contaminating the oil (diluting it) and that would account for the knocking/rattle.
POSTED BY: ROBERT GREGSON - NOWRA, NSW 6 SEP 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Ref your posting 6 Sep 08
I have a Toyota Hilux that sounds just as you explain and the dealers have already put £2500 worth of parts on it and the noise is still there. They say that it is normal, and refuse to do anything else to it.

We are in a position that we don’t know what we can do, when you pay £19000 for a Hilux and don’t expect to be treated like this. This Hilux is only 18 months old.
POSTED BY: MATHEW THOMAS - NORWICH NORFOLK, UNITED KINGDOM 17 SEP 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I have a Toyota Hilux 4x4 single cab and have a number of injectors replaced on my car. I think at last count 7 as well as other warranty issues but to go along with the injector problems I also have shocking fuel economy - it vary from 480km to 500km to a tank, at average 13L to 100kms. I also have had the same response talking to Toyota and have resorted to the ACCC but at this time have been told because I’m a registered company that they cannot help.

I am interested in hearing from anyone else that has had the same issues so I can work out which path I should take next.
POSTED BY: BRAD MCKEEVER - KILMORE, VIC - AUS 4 DEC 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I have an 07 Hilux with all the same problems. 13lts to 100km and has now dropped an injector... I had a chip fitted to try to improve the economy and of course now Toyota say that has void the warranty.

I have heard that it is illegal for them to void the warranty just because it has an after market product fitted unless they prove it caused the problem. If any one can shed some light on this, I would be grateful.
POSTED BY: ROWEN.STEWART - ST HELENS, TAS - AUS 16 FEB 2009

========== REPLY ==========
Depending on the euro spec or your Hilux the ecu can be reprogrammed to re-map the fuel system. Euro 3 spec cannot be fixed but Euro 4 spec can be... easy way to tell is if your Hilux has 3 rear head rests it is a Euro 4.
POSTED BY: MIKE TOYOTA TECH - NEW ZEALAND 14 MAR 2009

========== REPLY ==========
A mate of mine in MacKay Qld had same problem with noise and fuel burning and then blew a hole through piston. Toyota put new piston in only one cylinder, car has done 40000ks. Four weeks later yesterday blew hole through piston again. Toyota now has it again and he wants a new engine this time.
POSTED BY: FORDO - COLLINSVILLE, QLD - AUS 25 APR 2009

NISSAN NAVARA STX D40 2007:  RE: FULL OF IT     *REPLY*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

You guys don't have enough to winge about. I bought a new Jeep Cherokee (2005), and over a two year period had two new gearboxes replaced, Torque converter, Booster & master brake cylinders replaced, a diesel pre-heater contraption replaced (two weeks off the road) hand brake reassembled and the list goes on.

With the warranty period expiry date closing in I decided to replace it with a new Navara STX. I had the driver’s door mechanism go faulty on me, arranged with Cleveland Nissan to rectify. They offered to rectify immediately. They removed the identical part from a new vehicle and had me back on the road within an Hour.

New vehicles like everything else can & do go wrong. But to have a diesel leak (minor) is over the top and to go to these lengths of complaint, I think needs some attitude adjustment on the par of the owner. *EMAIL NOT SUPPLIED*

POSTED BY: GARTH  - BRISBANE, QLD, AUS, 31/08/2008 
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"NISSAN NAVARA STX D40 2007: FULL OF IT - In my last bleat about this car cutting out and losing power in which Nissan could not find the problem they have finally found the problem. I took it to them a week ago while it was playing up and they tell me it’s the fuel pump. Great! Let’s get a new pump and it will be sorted, 20 working day to get one from Europe. What a joke!

Then two days later or something they just happen to find 2 in Melbourne. In the mean time I have asked for a courtesy car as my piece of junk has been useless to me and my family {this going on for 2-3 months}. Now the place that’s doing the repairs have the pump and parts that were approved by Nissan. But now Nissan have done a back flip and told them not to touch the car {after it was sitting at Nissan for three days and didn't get touched}.

Now they want to replace the fuel rail. What For? When the mechanic diagnosed it as the fuel pump, now I got to wait until the fuel rail gets here. So now I will have to wait who knows how long for that, and all without a car. I'm fed up with this company and its product. I will not buy this brand ever again and I will certainly be going out of my way to voice my opinion to anyone who has thoughts of buying this model. I should have bought with my heart and not my head, a Ford."
POSTED BY: SCOTT MCINTYRE - BRISBANE, QLD, AUS 15/09/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Scott,
I understand your frustration. You should, in writing, ask some questions of Nissan Australia. Like why they are changing the fuel rail when the pump was diagnosed as the problem. Also ask why it takes so long for repairs to be carried out. Let them know that being without your work vehicle for days or weeks and having this problem for 3 months is totaly unacceptable and that you want to be compensated for it. Hopefully you might get a free service out of it. Post on this site how the Navara is after the repairs.
Good Luck,
Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC 16/9/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Scott,

I bought a Nissan Navara ST-X Turbo Diesel ONE week ago and it’s currently now back at the dealership getting fixed. I spotted Diesel leaking from underneath and called the Care line for a tow (from the country I might add, I wasn't happy at all).

Now it’s in at the dealership and they said that I need a new Fuel Injection pump and it could take a few days. I'm so mad that I might have just bought a Lemon of a car so I’m looking for anyone who might have had other issues with the brand. I don't believe the dealership at all (according to them my car it the first in Australia to have a problem, what a lot of **** I thought).

I have been doing a bit of research and found out Australia have no laws against dealerships selling lemon cars (Stupid Government). Although I have started a log of every time it goes in to the dealership and how long etc. It’s only One Week Old.

If you know of any other issues I should keep a eye out for let me know and while it’s under warranty I'm going to be the most annoying customer ever

Tanya
POSTED BY: TANYA WILKINSON - MELBOURNE, VIC 9/10/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Scott
I purchased a D40 STX Turbo Diesel Auto in Jan last year. What a pile of junk. I had mine for 9 months. It was in the workshop for warranty repairs for 5 days out of every 15 working days & I used it as my business car. Check out the UK forums on these things. They are still having the same warranty issues here that they had in the UK 2 years ago. Guess what Nissan Australia response is? My advice - get it back & get rid of it. Tell them you’re going to sell it & they will have the parts straight away.

I was told the heat shields would be three weeks away, after telling Nissan HQ what I was going to do after their appalling service they found the parts at the dealership within 1 hour. This model is a Lemon but our weak govt will not do anything about it. Check the 4wd forums in this country & do a search for D40 problems you are not alone.
Hope you get it sorted. Mike.
POSTED BY: MIKE CORBETT - BRISBANE, QLD 17/10/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Tanya
I have an STR turbo diesel 2003 model 40000kms on the clock .I have also had problems galore with this pile of ****. Firstly it was losing power not going over 40kms an hour then when I pulled over it would just stop so turn off the key and it goes for another 20mins and does it again. Took it in to Nissan and after 3 fuel filters it was then decided to clean out the tank (full removal) clean the lines and another filter. Only got about 10kms and the engine light comes on - water in the filter remember that was a new one.

Took it back the next day and it this time it was quite driveable with no power loss. They diagnosed with the computer, contaminated fuel code came up so nearly $4000.00 for a fuel injection pump.

I have my car back, for 3 weeks, was driving along and the engine light came on again no water in the fuel only basic fuel filter stuff but when I took it back in it was in limp mode and driving like a dog. They put the machine on again and guess what contaminated fuel code. So sent it to Melbourne at my expense but they said there was nothing wrong, as they would! Cleared the code and sent it back but can't explain the code.

2 weeks now, also a new lift pump and the labour etc another 700.00. I am ready to burn it and buy a Toyota no one can give me any answers. Nissan say they have not had this problem before and can't offer any suggestions as to why it's happening.

Joanne
POSTED BY: JOANNE BRAMBLE - COOMBA BAY, NSW, 4/1/2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Scott, I have a D40 too, no problems with my clutch yet but my diesel consumption went from under 9lt per 100kms up to around 16lt per 100. Other than resetting the computer, Nissan would not touch the vehicle, stating that it was still within spec. Tired of arguing for 9 months with Nissan and my local dealer, I spoke to Ray Miller of Turbo Engineering in Melbourne who diagnosed it over the phone as a stuck EGR valve and to get Nissan to fix it. The dealer would not touch it, so I took it to Ray and he dynoed the vehicle and fixed the EGR, (exhaust gas temp dropped from 650deg due to exhaust gasses constantly being fed back through the engine to 480). Fuel economy back is to normal.

The dealer still won’t admit there was a problem and pretty much told me I was a whinger. I like you will not buy this brand again.
POSTED BY: PAUL BAXA - COBRAM, VIC 3/2/2008

========== REPLY ==========
Problems with STX diesel rail replaced when pump should have been replaced had an oil leak in front of engine. Keeps going back to limp mode even through tunnel at 25km/hr came out shaking. Problem still not sorted out and another oil leak appeared. Went in to get fixed and they found the timing chain was longer one side than the other. Have not got vehicle back yet.

They hired a little Hyundai for my son to drive with all his tools for building - What A Put Down. Nissan Australia have been less than helpful over this issue, hopefully the timing chain will fix the problem. I am totally fed up over this whole issue and am considering going to the TV and papers.
POSTED BY: CHRIS - JAMESTOWN, SA 4/4/2008

HOLDEN ASTRA CITY 2004:  GOOD CAR SO FAR    *UPDATE*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
QUALITY

98000 ks and only tyres replaced so far. I hammer this car more often than I should, maybe I’ll do the original timing belt tomorrow and be 4 grand worse off. Maybe it will go to 120000 k, I feel for you folks who have had so much trouble with your Astras. I’ll keep you posted on my so far reliable, hardly maintained, driven hard little bus.

POSTED BY: GREGGY  - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Get that cam/timing belt changed urgently.... even Holden recommends no longer than 80k. I have done mine at 50k and will do again at 100k.

Keep your fingers crossed.
POSTED BY: CUSTER - BRISBANE, QLD - AUS 7 OCT 2008

FORD FALCON  2004:  RE: COOLANT LEAKAGE THERMOSTAT HOUSING     *REPLY*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
COOLING SYSTEM

Hi Jeff.
If the leak is "definitely" from the "O" ring at the thermo housing pipe. Check the position of the pipe, that it is not damaged/corroded and is sitting square with the housing. Apply a small amount of silicone sealant into the pipe groove prior to assembly.

If by "O ring" you mean the thermostat seal ring, I suggest you clean the ledge and reface or replace the cover (have seen some warped). Always use a new seal. There is also an issue with the bleed pipe (brass) at the cover coming loose. Remove, silicone/stag and tap back in or replace the cover.
Dav...

POSTED BY: L DAVIS - BOMADERRY, NSW - AUS, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"FORD FALCON BA 2004: COOLANT LEAKAGE THERMOSTAT HOUSING - I have replaced two "O" rings and thermostat housing in as many months. Still cannot contain seepage from housing (O Ring). Most of my Fords from AU onwards have had this problem with the simple fix of a new rubber O Ring, however this one has me stumped.

Would be glad to hear from anyone with same problem and fix.

Regards to all."
POSTED BY: JEFF HARPER - GEELONG, VIC, AUS 16 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Have come across this problem twice before and both times fixed the problem using Loctite Blue silicone. Run a bead around thermostat housing and tighten, make sure to still use rubber o-ring.
POSTED BY: BILL - BRISBANE, QLD 17 AUG 2008

FORD FALCON  1988:  RE: ENGINE MISFIRE ABOVE 1500 RPM     *REPLY*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

Hi Bill.
Is the concern a definite missfire on a particular cylinder or a general roughness in the motor?

A few items to check are.
Compression test.
Inlet manifold leak. (spray with water to locate).Don’t forget PCV valve.
Fuel pressure test. Security of injectors, have a look at the pattern while running and the sound they make.
Cleanliness of coil or cracks.
Distributor rotor or cap damage/cracks/gap.
Check for end float in crankshaft (this will also cause knocking)

Hope this gives you a few paths to take... Dav...

POSTED BY: L DAVIS - BOMADERRY, NSW - AUS, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"FORD FALCON EA 1988: ENGINE MISFIRE ABOVE 1500 RPM - This is the CFI or throttle body injection motor. I have replaced plugs & leads, have cleaned injectors but still the problem persists and seems only to be after the engine reaches operating temp.

Any ideas please?"
POSTED BY: BILL DOBELL - BALLARAT, VIC, AUS 30 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Thanks L Davis for your prompt reply, the problem is a definite misfire and is quite harsh especially under open throttle, it is usually only one miss but under heavy acceleration it becomes a series of rapid jerks and depending on the gear selected (Manual gearbox) it causes tyre squeal.

Despite the age of the engine 270,000 ks it idles relatively smooth and so I have at this stage ruled out uneven compression, I will however do a vacuum check ASAP.

I have had the injectors out and have also listened to them with no undue noise.

Distributor and rotor are OK.

I intend both replacing the coil and checking the full fuel delivery system from tank to throttle body and hope the coil will fix the problem.

Many thanks for your advice.

Bill
POSTED BY: BILL DOBELL - BALLARAT, VIC 31 AUG 2008

NISSAN PATROL 4.2TD  2001:  RE: 5TH GEAR STRIPPED. COMMON FAULT WITH MODEL BUT NO RECALL    *REPLY*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
DRIVETRAIN

I too have just blown 5th gear as early as today. Can you tell me how you went with this problem at Nissan Dealer?

POSTED BY: MARTIN MARTIN - PENRITH, NSW, AUS, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"NISSAN PATROL 4.2TD 2001: 5TH GEAR STRIPPED. COMMON FAULT WITH MODEL BUT NO RECALL. - Although 3 years out of warranty have only done 106,000 k`s. Before warranty expired on 12/04 contacted Nissan and was told that they would honour warranty within a reasonable time for common fault for this model of 5th gear spinning on drive shaft. They would not recall vehicles to rectify fault but issued kits to all dealers to cover the onslaught of failures.

Now it has happened and they don’t want to know about it.

Any advice on how I can push my case."
POSTED BY: CLIFF BURTON - PERTH, WA, AUS 28 NOV 2007

========== REPLY ==========
It is unreasonable to expect assistance from an auto manufacturer when your vehicle is so far out of warranty.
POSTED BY: FRANK BURRELL - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS 29 NOV 2007

LANDROVER FREELANDER  2003:  THOUSANDS $$$ ON REPAIRS FOR LOW MILEAGE FREELANDER    *COMPLAINT*

31/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

Same as the rest of you: constant expensive repairs, including head gasket leaks leading to engine meltdown. My Freelander has never gone 1000 miles without needing service. I am lucky to have an extended warranty, but the dealer and insurance company are trying to put in a rebuilt (****) engine with a 60 Day Warranty. That means I'll be chasing them again in two months. I've had so little use out of this car, it's laughable. It looks brand new because it never goes anywhere other than the repair shop.

So my question is: Is anyone holding Land Rover USA accountable? These cars should have been recalled. I've heard rumors of class action suits and Lemon Law rulings. Can anyone tell me who/what/where?

Thanks and good luck everyone.

Jay

POSTED BY: JAY LARMAN - MIAMI BEACH, USA, 31/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK

TOYOTA HILUX SR 2007:  RE: NO TORQUE, HAS NO POWER ALONG WITH FUEL ECONOMY     *REPLY*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

Had the same fuel issue with my 07 SR twin cab, fuel light would come on between 480 - 500km. Been hounding them for a while because fuel economy has gone from 10 litres/100km to 13 litres/100km and sometimes as bad as 16 litres/100km. Toyota think they have finally found the problem which is one faulty injector. They say the flow is that high through that one that the computer is actually cutting the flow to the other 3 to compensate.

It was only found when left there for about a week with them checking it every morning as the cold weather exaggerates the problem. It is still there waiting for parts so hopefully it fixes the fuel economy problem. It will still do a top speed of 170km/h and it has a steel tray and arb bullbar and winch but this might explain why yours loses power if the computer is cutting flow to the good injectors.

POSTED BY: NICK CORBO - TATURA, VIC, AUS, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"TOYOTA HILUX SR 3.0L TD 2008: NO TORQUE, HAS NO POWER ALONG WITH FUEL ECONOMY - I recently bought a new 3.0L TD SR dual cab Hilux 08 model. I am very disappointed with the performance of the vehicle as I can't get it to go any quicker than 125km hr & this is without towing or a load on the back. The vehicle to get up a hill will do max 80km hr if we are lucky and that is only a small hill. I have also found that I am only getting around 500km to a tank.

I have had this problem since the purchase of the vehicle & all I can get out of Toyota is that my tray must be too heavy with a weight of 2240 compared to the GVM being 2780. I can’t see how this is the problem. I can’t even get them to dyno test the vehicle to see if there is a problem."
POSTED BY: STEVEN SINCLAIR - COWRA, NSW, AUS 1 AUG 2008

MITSUBISHI PAJERO  2001:  RE: TEMP GAUGE     *REPLY*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
COOLING SYSTEM

Hi Ross

I have a 2001 NM GLX 3500 auto and just started experiencing the same issues as you described. Have replaced the thermostat and taken to Mitsubishi. They have advised it is the Temp sensor in the ECU Cluster. The car was found to be working in normal temp zones.

I am interested to hear your outcome.

Thanks, Jaime

POSTED BY: JAIME PATULLO - BRISBANE , QLD, AUS, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"MITSUBISHI PAJERO NM 2001: TEMP GAUGE - Fitted new thermostat and sender unit temp gauge fluctuates is any other problem apart from gauge and how to replace."
POSTED BY: ROSS SENDALL - HERVEY BAY, QLD, AUS 16 JUL 2008

MITSUBISHI PAJERO NM 2001:  OVERHEATING TOLD IT IS ECU FAILURE WITH TEMP GAUGE     *FEEDBACK WANTED*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
COOLING SYSTEM

Any advice on the possibility someone else has experienced the rapid increase in temp and then decrease. Could be radiator block but could also be this gauge as the Mitsubishi dealer has advised.

Thanks.

POSTED BY: JAIME PATULLO - BRISBANE , QLD, AUS, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
If you are not losing any water, then the gauge or sender unit may be the problem. If the vehicle rapidly overheats, it should be throwing out water.
Good Luck
Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC 31 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I am having a similar problem with my NM Pajero 2000 GLS. From cold after about 10 minutes of running the temperature gauge goes to the hot mark then quickly drops back to the normal temperature. It will then go up and down between normal and hot. I have monitored the head temperature while this is happening and the head temp sits between 75-85C. I would be interested to know if you solved the problem and if so what was the problem?

Regards, Brendan
POSTED BY: BRENDAN - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS 4 OCT 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Had the same problem with 2001 NM Pajero. There was a recall on the radiator which was replaced at no cost, but I still had the same problem with the temperature gauge. They ended up pulling the instrument panel out of the dash and sending it away where it was found to have a faulty module.
POSTED BY: DARREN MAXWELL - DUBBO, NSW - AUS 2 DEC 2008

NISSAN NAVARA 4X4 STX 2007:  RE: CUTS OUT     *REPLY*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
FUEL SYSTEM

A word of advice concerning your engine cut out while the fuel light is on and on a hill. Don’t let your fuel get to the point where your light registers dummy. Especially on a hill... 2+2+=4 or in your case 3. Cheers Matt.

POSTED BY: MATT  - BRISBANE, QLD, AUS, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"NISSAN NAVARA 4X4 DUAL CAB STX 2007: CUTS OUT - Only 2 days old, and my new turbo diesel 4x4 Navara stops about 3klm after the fuel light comes on. This has happened 3 times so far, each time I have been out in the countryside on a slope (slight).

Nissan said they can repair the problem, but they had to order the part in from overseas. I booked it in, but happened again when I drove out of there. So no luck when they fitted it, if they did. I have still to see where we go from here. I saw a New Zealand issue the same.

How many other people have this problem?"
POSTED BY: GLEN JACOBS - CANBERRA, ACT, AUS 1 OCT 2007

========== REPLY ==========
I have had 2 2007 STX diesel Navara's and both will do over 60km from the time the fuel light comes on. Wouldn't think it would be a hard problem to fix, either the fuel pick up or the low warning switch is incorrectly positioned and simply needs to be adjusted (bent, tweaked or similar). Take it to someone who thinks outside the square and give Nissan the invoice for fixing it. Try Dave at the Garage that does LPG in Mawson. Cheers Gary
POSTED BY: GARY - CHRISTCHURCH, NEW ZEALAND 2/10/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Don't let Nissan muck you around on this! I had a lot of trouble with them over this problem with mine. It seems that the fuel return line is not putting fuel back into the pickup cup. Nissan has modified my D40 but refuses to acknowledge there is a fault. Marty
POSTED BY: MARTY - WELLINGTON, NEW ZEALAND 23/12/2007

NISSAN NAVARA D40 2007:  RE: FRONT DISC ROTORS     *REPLY*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
BRAKES

David,

I have the same issue with Nissan that rotors and pads need to be replaced at 44,000kms. I don't tow with the vehicle and a large % of travel is in country on flat roads so I don't know how they can call it excessive braking. Did you get any satisfaction from Nissan i.e. did they replace under warranty? I don't feel like forking out $700.00 every 45,000kms. My previous STR achieved 200,000kms before rotors needed to be replaced? Any advice would be appreciated.

Ian

POSTED BY: IAN BUSSENSCHUTT - ADELAIDE, SA, AUS, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"NISSAN NAVARA D40 2007: FRONT DISC ROTORS - At 20,000 service told the discs and pads will not last until the 30,000k service. They will need to be done by 26,000 or the warranty will be void. The dealer said I am too hard on the brakes. I asked how come I got 112,000k out of the front discs on my Toyo 80 series. I think it is a bad batch of rotors not my driving style. Has anybody had this problem?"
POSTED BY: GREG CONWAY - BRISBANE, QLD, AUS 31 MAY 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I have the 4x2 manual V6 and after 14k I could see there were issues with the cheap nasty factory rotors. I organised a complete change and now run DBA drilled and slotted rotors with Ceramic Pads made by Hawke in the US. Compfriction in NSW modified the pads to suit. Truck now stops better with zero black dust and so far showing no signs of ware. There are 2 of us in Canberra running same set up and a few others interstate with different pads and rotors.

There are a few of us Aus wide in a US forum called Clubfrontier.Org. Feel free to drop in and join us, its free, and we can try to help out with any issues you might have. Just in case you’re curious, the Navara is called a Frontier in Nth America. The D40 is produced and sold world wide.

Cheers
Paul
POSTED BY: PAUL HINCHY - CANBERRA, ACT - AUS 11/6/2008

========== REPLY ==========
I have a 2006 model D40 with 45000 and was told by dealer that I also need new rotors and pads. I couldn't believe it as I had only 1 set of rotors machined and 3 sets of pads on my 75 series Cruiser in 300,000 kms. I always carried a lot more weight in the Cruiser. I have a mate with an auto D40 with 65000kms and his brakes are still fine. Really hard to understand this but workshop manager in Cairns Nissan told me that the rotors wear quicker than the pads.
POSTED BY: DAVID MAYNARD - CAIRNS, QLD - AUS 29 AUG 2008

KIA CARNIVAL  2000:  RE: NEW ENGINE     *REPLY*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

I have a 2000 Carnival 149,000 km. I've had it from new and I have oil in the radiator water and water in the engine oil. Can you help me with how to get the most out of Kia.

Regards Stephen.

POSTED BY: STEPHEN HALL - LESMURDIE, WA, AUS, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Gayleen

First things first. You need to establish what your problem is. "Overheating" could be caused by one of a hundred things including failing to put coolant in the car.

The classic sign to look for is Oil in the radiator or overflow tank where you top up your engine water. If this is the case your engine is one that is affected by a manufacturing fault that Kia is aware of but refuse to acknowledge.

If you reply to me I can forward you all the information you need to get up to speed on this problem. When you reply could you confirm if there is oil in the coolant.

Now this is important if it is this fault you have to get a Kia dealer to lodge an official request with Kia Motors Australia for them to pay the bill.

Their first response from the Kia dealer to you will be that you are wasting your time but insist they do this. Weeks later when you do get anyone at Kia Motors to return your call they will tell you you should have done this (I'm talking about a Kia Dealer not the dealer you bought the car from).

If it is this fault the engine will fail again yes that's right will fail again so it is important that it is fixed by a Kia dealer so that they can't come back at you with "it should have been fixed by an authorised dealer".

To answer your other question no they don't put a new motor in from the latest model Carnival. They fix your existing engine to its original manufacturing / design specification defects & all. Then they cross their fingers & hope they have got rid of you.

Now the news isn't all bad. A number of us are slowly gathering examples like yours to lodge a class action against Kia & make them pay back everyone affected. I would love to say that this will happen next week or the week after that but these things take time but with us all working together Kia’s day in court will come.

Regards, Dale
POSTED BY: DALE MORRIS - WOODVALE, WA, AUS 20 AUG 2008

========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"KIA CARNIVAL 2004: NEW ENGINE - Hi All,

I don’t know if I should consider this good news but the car yard (from whom I’m still covered by their 3mth/5000k warranty) have arranged for my car to get a new motor. They had my car towed on Monday from my mechanic to theirs. I don’t feel comfortable with this, as I don’t know this mechanic and his work, but what do you do. I will be going to this mechanics workshop tomorrow to get an update on progress, if any yet.

Can anyone tell me what motors are in the 2008 Kias, are they the same as 2004 with same overheating problems? (surely they won’t replace with same lemon 2004 motor). I still can’t believe that Kia have done nothing about this problem. There are a lot of Kias on the road, I never knew there was a problem with them.

My mechanic was disgusted with this problem, he too went on this site over the weekend.

Thanks Gayleen"
POSTED BY: GAYLEEN HOPKINS - FARMBOROUGH HEIGHTS, NSW, AUS 19 AUG 2008

NISSAN ALTIMA  2007:  RE: **** PAINT TO START WITH NOW MADE EVEN WORSE THANKS TO NISSAN    *REPLY*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
PAINT

I have a 2007 Altima. The paint is pitted on the front bumper and grill area, also a section on the running boards in front of the rear tires look like it was sandblasted. It has 29000miles but this should not be happening. I took it to the dealer and the service manager told it is road abrasion and Nissan will not cover it or repair it. I also showed him the orange peel look of the paint on the entire car and his response was "that’s Nissan paint". The color is dark metallic blue and the luster is totally gone on the front end.

I contacted Nissan and they go along with the service manager and will not fix it, case closed, will not except a second opinion. I'm really **** and don't intend to give up. I'm not sure what my next move should be. Any suggestions would be great. Nissan doesn't really care if your satisfied with their product. I even asked to speak to a "higher up", and was told that was not possible. Pretty much, too bad for me. This will be the Last Nissan I buy!

POSTED BY: JEFF KRAATZ - FREEDOM, NEW YORK , USA, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"NISSAN NAVARA D40 ST-X 2006: **** PAINT TO START WITH NOW MADE EVEN WORSE THANKS TO NISSAN - I brought my paint issues to the attention of Nissan representatives some 3 days after taking delivery of my Nissan Navara 2006 ST-X D40 4x2 in Midnight Black. Being a black vehicle it is very easy to see if there are any issues with the paint. Upon polishing the vehicle I found there were many inclusions in the paint. Long story short, 14 months later and Nissan has agreed to take the vehicle to their workshops to repair the paintwork.

7 weeks later I go to inspect the vehicle and in my opinion it is now in much worse condition than it was when delivered for repair. I brought this to the attention of the certain Customer Service person who organised this fiasco and was told that Nissan had done all it was going to do and that I had no choice but to accept my vehicle back. Ok so you can guess that didn’t happen.

I have been speaking with another person at Nissan who apparently is the Boss of the person I was dealing with and they have assured me that this will all be resolved this coming week and that I will be happy with the outcome. In short I have stated that I will only be happy to receive my vehicle back once it has been fully resprayed as the work that was done has basically destroyed the factory paint work. Other alternatives I will accept is a new vehicle or a full refund.

Anyone else that has had issues with the paint on the Nissan Navara D40 please speak up so I can have yet more information to take to Nissan. I know of issues with the paint on vehicles from other countries. All D40 trucks were painted in Spain until somewhere through 2007 I believe."
POSTED BY: PAUL HINCHY - CANBERRA, ACT, AUS 8 JUN 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I washed my STX on the weekend to find a gold mark on my grey paint work. Had a good look to find a high spot in the paint and the clear coat had gone a goldy colour. Gave it a polish by hand and the gold spot was gone, but back to the undercoat, Nissan are having a look this week. Between the speedo issue being 8% out and the dodgy paint work this vehicle has been a real let down. Nissan really need to have a good look at themselves.
POSTED BY: LEIGH SKINNER - COBDEN, VIC, AUS 17 JUN 2008

FORD FALCON EA 1988:  ENGINE MISFIRE ABOVE 1500 RPM    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

30/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

This is the CFI or throttle body injection motor. I have replaced plugs & leads, have cleaned injectors but still the problem persists and seems only to be after the engine reaches operating temp.

Any ideas please?

POSTED BY: BILL DOBELL - BALLARAT, VIC, AUS, 30/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Hi Bill.
Is the concern a definite missfire on a particular cylinder or a general roughness in the motor?

A few items to check are.
Compression test.
Inlet manifold leak. (spray with water to locate).Don’t forget PCV valve.
Fuel pressure test. Security of injectors, have a look at the pattern while running and the sound they make.
Cleanliness of coil or cracks.
Distributor rotor or cap damage/cracks/gap.
Check for end float in crankshaft (this will also cause knocking)

Hope this gives you a few paths to take... Dav...
POSTED BY: L DAVIS - BOMADERRY, NSW 31 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Thanks L Davis for your prompt reply, the problem is a definite misfire and is quite harsh especially under open throttle, it is usually only one miss but under heavy acceleration it becomes a series of rapid jerks and depending on the gear selected (Manual gearbox) it causes tyre squeal.

Despite the age of the engine 270,000 ks it idles relatively smooth and so I have at this stage ruled out uneven compression, I will however do a vacuum check ASAP.

I have had the injectors out and have also listened to them with no undue noise.

Distributor and rotor are OK.

I intend both replacing the coil and checking the full fuel delivery system from tank to throttle body and hope the coil will fix the problem.

Many thanks for your advice.

Bill
POSTED BY: BILL DOBELL - BALLARAT, VIC 31 AUG 2008

MITSUBISHI MAGNA TR 1991:  RE: CAR STOPS     *REPLY*

29/08/2008

ISSUE:
ELECTRICAL

Hi Paul,

Had exactly the same problem with my Magna TR. Turned out to be the Computer located behind the kick panel at the passengers feet. I removed it, not much work in doing this and I replaced all the Electrolytic Capacitors, about 6 in all. You would need to have a technician do this. Once this was done there has not been another bit of trouble from it.

The Auto transmission computer will also cause gear change problems when the capacitors fail in it. It is a similar computer and is located right on the hump under the centre of the dash board, a little more difficult to remove. Have a technician change the capacitors in it to prevent troubles with the transmission.

The capacitors only cost a couple of dollars from Dick Smith but to do it you need the technician. Perhaps a TV tech will do it for you if you take it to him.

This will fix it.

Cheers Howard.

POSTED BY: HOWARD  - BRISBANE, QLD, AUS, 29/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"MITSUBISHI MAGNA TR 1991: CAR STOPS - Hi, bought this TR Magna Elite 2.6 Fuel injected car. Had 100,000 on the clock & has since done 17,000 since. Lately it has decided to stop for no reason, we wait a few minutes & the car re starts. I have changed the distributor, coil, power transistor, control relay, throttle position sensor and idle speed control motor. All seemed well & I thought it was fixed. It has run well for a couple of days and out of the blue it has just decided to stop again.

When it runs it goes like a dream, the computer doesn't indicate any problem (no check engine light) the air flow sensor seems OK. I don't think it’s the injection system (fuel) as the engine runs fine when it goes. I would appreciate any help as I'm running out of ideas."
POSTED BY: PAUL FINNERTY - SUMMER HILL, NSW, AUS 31 MAY 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Could be faulty ECU.
POSTED BY: PHIL - NORTHLAND, NEW ZEALAND 2/6/2008

========== REPLY ==========
Your battery is ****. I had the same problem in my 2002 model.

Cheers, Jim
POSTED BY: JIM CHAPMAN - PERTH, WA 9 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi buddy, I have the same Magna and is doing the same! Spent a lot of time trying to get it working and would like to know if you have found out what is wrong?
POSTED BY: JAMIE - HOBART, TAS - AUS 20 AUG 2008

NISSAN NAVARA D40 2006:  RE: FRONT DISC ROTORS     *REPLY*

29/08/2008

ISSUE:
BRAKES

I have a 2006 model D40 with 45000 and was told by dealer that I also need new rotors and pads. I couldn't believe it as I had only 1 set of rotors machined and 3 sets of pads on my 75 series Cruiser in 300,000 kms. I always carried a lot more weight in the Cruiser. I have a mate with an auto D40 with 65000kms and his brakes are still fine. Really hard to understand this but workshop manager in Cairns Nissan told me that the rotors wear quicker than the pads.

POSTED BY: DAVID MAYNARD - CAIRNS, QLD, AUS, 29/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"NISSAN NAVARA D40 2007: FRONT DISC ROTORS - At 20,000 service told the discs and pads will not last until the 30,000k service. They will need to be done by 26,000 or the warranty will be void. The dealer said I am too hard on the brakes. I asked how come I got 112,000k out of the front discs on my Toyo 80 series. I think it is a bad batch of rotors not my driving style. Has anybody had this problem?"
POSTED BY: GREG CONWAY - BRISBANE, QLD, AUS 31 MAY 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I have the 4x2 manual V6 and after 14k I could see there were issues with the cheap nasty factory rotors. I organised a complete change and now run DBA drilled and slotted rotors with Ceramic Pads made by Hawke in the US. Compfriction in NSW modified the pads to suit. Truck now stops better with zero black dust and so far showing no signs of ware. There are 2 of us in Canberra running same set up and a few others interstate with different pads and rotors.

There are a few of us Aus wide in a US forum called Clubfrontier.Org. Feel free to drop in and join us, its free, and we can try to help out with any issues you might have. Just in case you’re curious, the Navara is called a Frontier in Nth America. The D40 is produced and sold world wide.

Cheers
Paul
POSTED BY: PAUL HINCHY - CANBERRA, ACT - AUS 11/6/2008

========== REPLY ==========
David,
I have the same issue with Nissan that rotors and pads need to be replaced at 44,000kms. I don't tow with the vehicle and a large % of travel is in country on flat roads so I don't know how they can call it excessive braking. Did you get any satisfaction from Nissan i.e. did they replace under warranty? I don't feel like forking out $700.00 every 45,000kms. My previous STR achieved 200,000kms before rotors needed to be replaced? Any advice would be appreciated.

Ian
POSTED BY: IAN BUSSENSCHUTT - ADELAIDE, SA - AUS 30 AUG 2008

PEUGEOT 206 XR 2001:  RE: PEUGEOT 206 IS A LEMON.     *REPLY*

28/08/2008

ISSUE:
ENGINE

I am so relieved to see that someone is having the same issues with their 206 as me. I was driving on a major highway out of Wollongong on the weekend when all of a sudden my car Died and had to be towed. They are now telling me that the first cylinder is not combusting it has to be replaced costing $6500! What a crazy amount especially when my car is only worth $19K.

I feel like my car is an absolute Lemon! I have had problem after problem! The service people seem to have no idea what they are doing and I am left 4 days after the event still not knowing the final details My only option now is to sell it.

POSTED BY: REBECCA  - SYDNEY, NSW, AUS, 28/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"PEUGEOT 206 XR 2001: PEUGEOT 206 IS A LEMON. - I've had my Peugeot 206 for approx 5yrs now and it's been such an unpleasant car to drive. I bought the automatic transmission version. As soon as I drove the car out of the showroom the car had problems straight away. It had what I have been told engine flair. Which is when you take off from a stationary position the engine would over rev and not go anywhere. Took it back to Peugeot and they fixed it.

Next problem I had was the head gasket needed replacing which I had done under warranty and all this within the first year. The brakes wear out too quick and constantly need changing. The second problem I had was that the way they have designed the gear shift arm that changes the vehicle from reverse to drive was that it was rubbing on some wiring under the battery enclosure which over time caused the wires to completely break away from the battery contact point. Lucky my mate is a mechanic and he located and fixed the problem for a bottle of whisky.

It's in its fifth year of existence now and the head gasket is being replaced yet again by my mate. My mate who now tells me that not only does the head gasket need replacing but the engine is wearing out and will need to be rebuilt if I want to keep the car. He said the engine probably has worn out because Peugeot didn't replace the head gasket properly the first time which has lead to engine wear five years down the track.

The automatic transmission in this vehicle is the worst designed transmission if ever. Peugeot have what is called an engine break safety system. Basically the car is meant to drive like a manual in that when you slow own it gears down and pulls the car up. That's all well and good but I found myself constantly fighting against this engine break as the vehicle would shuffle between gears trying to find the right gear to sit in so I constantly had my foot on the execrator sitting just over 60kph to keep it in gear. I always felt like I was driving with the hand brake on. Peugeot make great looking vehicles but in my opinion they wear out too quickly and drive like ****.

Hope this helps."
POSTED BY: WARREN HUGHES - GLENROY, VIC - AUS 22 MAY 2007

========== REPLY ==========
Dear Rebecca, sorry to hear about your problems with your Peugeot 206. I used to work with sales in a Peugeot Dealership for many years and the description of your problem doesn't sound right. Also, even allowing for an exchange rate of 2 dollars to the UK pound, £3250 for an engine misfire? Either they have to replace an extremely expensive cylinder head, an expensive engine, or the wages for a mechanic in Australia must be the envy of the world, that equates to 30000 dollars a week! A second opinion sounds right.

Generally speaking, with the Peugeot brand, it’s the electronics which can give some issues, the rest of the cars don't give any more or less trouble than other brands. With our wetter climate, brake discs, exhausts and wheel bearings have a shorter life. Doesn't Australia have a motoring organisation which gives independent advice?

Regards, Bryan.
POSTED BY: BRYAN STOUT - FORFAR, ANGUS - SCOTLAND 17 SEP 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi, I am in WA. I bought a Peugeot 206 2007-2006, it was a brand new car. Originally I bought the car from Allpike by which this was another mistake as the service from both the sales and service was disgraceful. They made one error after another, then I started taking to Prestige Motor (which are part of DVG Group). They have been great help with this so called European car, as I have had BMW's and VW in the past. I thought being a European car it would be as reliable as them.

The issues start with car first - it was a constant issue with the gearbox which it wants to change gears when in manual mode. They say they fixed it but the service management say that they may never know whether or not it is fixed or not. The computer that should give information on faults does not register these faults.

I have had this car now for a year and half and it was the worst thing I have ever done. I will never buy another French car again.

I am also getting a group of people together who like me have these problems and have exhausted all options including approaching Peugeot Australia who don't want a bar of it. I am going to the Media with this issue and I am also going to Ministry of Fair Trading as I feel that I have spent $50,000 on a absolute lemon and nobody seem to give **** with other issues I have been having with this car.
POSTED BY: THOMAS - PERTH, WA - AUS 16 NOV 2008

LANDROVER FREELANDER  2000:  RE: FIGHT THEM ALL THE WAY     *REPLY*

28/08/2008

ISSUE:
COOLING SYSTEM

I currently have Land Rover Australia in court over total failure of my TD6 Range Rover twice at over 80kph at night on country roads. Unfortunately the CTTT was unable to handle it and it is now in the District Court. Land Rover now refuses to repair any warranty issues. If I can help let me know!

Richard

POSTED BY: RICHARD JONES - ARMIDALE, NSW, AUS, 28/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"LANDROVER FREELANDER 2000: FIGHT THEM ALL THE WAY - In response to all the consumers out there who are having problems with their Freelanders Blown Head Gasket.

We have had the same problem where we have fixed it once and 3 months later it went back to the repairers with exactly the same problem. After pointless phone calls to Landrover we referred the matter to the Motor Vehicle Repair Industry. It is now in the hands of the CTTT and we will be having a hearing with them and Landrover for a decision as to who is at fault.

I would like to thank everyone for their complaints as I will be using them for my case. To all People involved you should contact the Motors Vehicle Repair Industry and also the CTTT. Our hearing is on the 12th July. I will let everyone know how we get on. Also it would probably be a good idea if we contacted the media on this, anyone wishing to do so let me know."
POSTED BY: ANASTASIA ANDREWS - WHIAN WHIAN, NSW - AUS 13 JUN 2007

========== REPLY ==========
Please can you let me know how your hearing went as I have had similar problems.
Not sure what CTTT stands for?
Thanks.
POSTED BY: ESTHER - MELBOURNE, VIC 17 AUG 2007

========== REPLY ==========
My car has been at the mechanics now for 3 days. The fuel pump on my 2003 "Free"lander broke and had to be replaced 12 months ago. 6 months ago the rear driver power window unit had to be replaced, now the car overheated suddenly a few days ago and so far I have been told by the mechanic & auto elec the automatic fan for the engine is cutting off-resulting in engine overheating! The best part is they reckon sourcing the part is near impossible. Just absolutely ridiculous.

This model of car should have had a permanent recall on it as the Freelanders from the start have been **** lemons. The very first Freelander we had blew an engine at 5000kms - should never have bought another one! If you are thinking of purchasing one of these money pits on wheels - Don't.

Can you please let us know how the matter went at the CTTT? Thanks
POSTED BY: LOUISE - SYDNEY, NSW 20 OCT 2007

========== REPLY ==========
Eager to hear how you went in your hearing July of last year? Could not find any postings after comments in June of 07.

Yeah I have a Freelander, no need to go into the issues I have had with this vehicle. The worst 4x4 by far.

Cheers, Julian
POSTED BY: JULIAN - SYDNEY, NSW 9 JAN 2008

========== UPDATE ==========
I am writing in response as to how we got on with the CTTT.

Landrover was ordered to carry out repairs to our vehicle with a new engine at no cost to us. It was a long and stressful battle but we finally got our vehicle back which is now up for sale. I advise everyone to pursue their matters with Landrover as they should not getting away with what they are doing. If anybody would like a copy of the order that was made send me an email and I would be more than happy to forward it on.

Good luck all.
POSTED BY: ANASTASIA ANDREWS - WHIAN WHIAN, NSW 11 JAN 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Anastasia,
I'd like a copy of the order please. I wonder if you could post it on this site for all to see? Maybe delete your personal details.
Thanks,
Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN, MELBOURNE, VIC 12 JAN 2008

========== REPLY ==========
If someone could please help me with some information that would be great, as we are sinking as of right now with our 2003 Freelander with the same cooling problem. Well it has 89000 miles on it and now since the overheating of the car because of the fact that it kept losing coolant we are know having to pay $6000.00 for a new motor that we really don’t have!

Our car is at a certified mechanics shop that does work on foreign cars, so I have contacted Land Rover and they are now telling me that if Land Rover approves the motor for our vehicle then we can purchase one (have you ever heard of such). They also said that they can not get motors for these vehicles and that there has been many problems with this happening so I asked if they were doing a recall on this anytime soon? and they stated they don’t see that happening! Also they stated that the motors in the Freelanders pretty much go to **** after 50000 miles, they told my mechanic this!

So when I spoke to a gentleman in the parts department he stated that the only way that they are approving these repairs to the engine is if you have warranty or an extended warranty through Land Rover, which of course our warranty ran out at the 50,000 miles.

I mean we probably owe 17000 dollars on this car and it is just really stressful because Land Rover is not getting me anywhere with this case. So if someone could send some information on this that would be great, phone numbers to the cttt and the motor vehicle repair industry. Also I did see where someone had asked about taking it public and I am for that because this is not fair! That we are paying for vehicles and mine is still sitting in the shop not moving. Please Help!
POSTED BY: BRANDY MOERER - SCOTTSBURG, IN USA 21 FEB 2008

========== REPLY ==========
I have a 2005 that I purchased used with 37,000 miles. A month after and about 2k miles the motor started tapping (clearly lifters). Was told by Landrover that this is normal for this model. After several trips to the Landrover dealer they finally put it in the shop (2 weeks in the shop).

Drove another 2-3k guess what? Lifter noise! Back in the shop this time for 3-4 weeks. Landrover replaced the lifters because several were flat. Drove for 800 miles service engine light came on. Back to Landrover (evap leak) replaced gas cap (1 week in shop).

200 miles service, engine light, back to Landrover (evap leak) replaced sensor (1 week in shop). Drove about 2k miles service light back on (replaced Intake) 4 weeks in shop!

At about 49k lifter noise back getting real close to warranty, back to Landrover (replaced all lifters valves and machined heads replaced timing belts) 6 weeks in shop! Drove 8k with lifter noise spacer between crank pulley and motor broke; cut the timing belt bent all the valves and broke all the valve guides. Was told by Landrover No Warranty even though they made all the repairs during the warranty period.

Now I have a 2005 Freelander with 57k waiting for a motor that is on international back order. I have after market warranty that will cover the repairs but with a used motor. What can I do? Can anyone help me? I fear this used motor will have the same issues.
POSTED BY: BOBBY WOODIE - PIPE CREEK, TEXAS USA 6 MAR 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hello, I have a 1999 Freelander that has the same problems as yours did. I have been told I require a new motor, as well as being told how notorious they are for this problem. I am wondering if you could please send me the details of CTTT decision. I would be very keen to talk to you about this if you have the time. I appreciate any help you can provide.

Regards,
POSTED BY: OWEN DAWES - NEWCASTLE, NSW - AUS 4 APR 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Owen

The K Series Rover motor is a 1.8, it is the same as the motor in the Kia Carnival 2.5. Both where build by Powertrain LTD for Rover England, company no longer trading.

Cheers Peter
POSTED BY: PETER - TAMWORTH, NSW -AUS 11 MAY 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi, same problem with our Freelander that our 18 year old drives.
Wondering if you have any advice for me from your experience.
Thanks.
POSTED BY: FRANK CASALENUOVO - LOS ANGELES, USA 11 MAY 2008

========== REPLY ==========
RE: Freelander blown head.

Same problem in Australia. There is a solution and it works. First it is a design fault. The thermostat is in the head and the gasket that separates it from the rest of the engine is to thin, not enough gasket between it and the motor and will blow out and warp the head and cost you money.

Solution = you need a gasket that blocks out the thermostat housing, you move the thermostat into the return hose to the radiator. Have the head machined and put back together.

I do not know if this is Land Rover's solution to this or not, it does work. I have had it done to my '98 Freelander, it is going great since. I have just returned from a 4000 km trip to the mountains and snow. Went like a charm, I hope this works for you. Next car I will go back to a Disco.

Regards William Gray.
POSTED BY: WILLIAM GRAY - MELBOURNE, VIC, AUS 20 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Richard,
Please post a reply here when the court battle is over.
Good luck,
Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC 30 AUG 2008

PRESS-RELEASE VACC  2008:  GOVERNMENT CAR TAX REPORT DISAPPOINTINGLY PREDICTABLE    *PRESS RELEASE*

28/08/2008

ISSUE:
TAX

VACC, the peak automotive industry body in Victoria, has dismissed a Government report by the Senate Economics Committee on Luxury Car Tax (LCT) as disappointingly predictable and missing the point.

VACC wants LCT abolished and has questioned the legality of the Government’s retrospective application of an increase from 25 per cent to 33 per cent, as outlined in May’s Federal Budget.

VACC Executive Director, Mr David Purchase, said that consumers and retailers in the automotive industry will be disappointed with the twisted logic applied by the Government Senators on the Committee when they concluded that there is ‘…some merit in the argument that it is unfair that luxury cars are taxed but not other luxury purchases such as yachts or expensive artworks and jewellery. However, as there is already a luxury cars tax, there are less administrative and compliance costs in increasing it, rather than introducing new taxes on other luxury goods’.

“Are the Government Senators on the Committee seriously suggesting that cars should attract an increased tax because it is too hard to tax other luxury goods?” Mr Purchase said.

“Or might it be that the Government is actually considering introducing other luxury taxes, when the Government Senators added in their report ‘…introducing more general luxury taxes should await the Henry Review of the tax system’,” he said.

VACC is concerned new-car dealers may find themselves in an invidious position as Government and consumers disagree over who is to collect the retrospective increase. The report states: ‘the vendors (new car dealers) of a vehicle are responsible for paying the tax and it is a matter for their commercial judgementwhether or how they pass on the tax on to their customers’.

Mr Purchase disagrees. “Governments must change taxes in a responsible manner and not in a way that causes the chaos we have seen in the new car market from May to now, since the increase in the Luxury Car Tax was announced. Retrospective application of taxes such as has been applied by the Government, in this case, is a dangerous precedent.

“The Report of the Government Senators reveals that they did not care about the impact of the chaotic trading conditions caused by the poor implementation process applied by the Australian Tax Office and supported by the Government in relation to this matter.

“In a dissenting Report from Coalition Senators, consideration was given to increasing the threshold of Luxury Car Tax and other issues impacting on consumers and the automotive industry.

“The dissenting Report recommends that the proposed increase in the Luxury Car Tax be opposed in the Senate. VACC will be seeking that the Senate take note of the dissenting report made by Senators Eggleston, Abetz, Joyce and Bushby,” Mr Purchase said.

POSTED BY: VICTORIAN AUTOMOTIVE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS, 28/08/2008 

PRESS-RELEASE VACC  2008:  VACC CHALLENGES LEGALITY OF LUXURY CAR TAX INCREASE    *PRESS RELEASE*

28/08/2008

ISSUE:
TAX

VACC, the peak automotive industry body in Victoria, is challenging the legality of the Government’s retrospective application of the so-called “luxury car tax”.

In May’s Federal Budget, Treasurer Wayne Swan announced the tax on vehicles priced $57,123 and over would rise from 25 percent to 33 percent.

VACC has recently made written submissions on Luxury Car Tax (LCT) to both the Senate Economics Committee and the Review of Australia’s Automotive Industry by former Victoria State Premier, Mr Steve Bracks. A Senate Committee is due to present its report on the LCT increase today.

“VACC is opposed to the LCT both as it stands now and the proposed increase. Our view is, it should be abolished,” VACC Executive Director, David Purchase, said.

“If it is to remain, then the threshold should be increased to at least $75,000 and preferably to $100,000.

“LCT singles out cars as luxury items while no other goods, we are aware of, attract a luxury tax. It is, therefore, discriminatory.

“The proposal to back-date any increase in LCT flies in the face of accepted taxation principles. The announced retrospective collection has created confusion in the market place and anger among consumers,” he said.

VACC has engaged the legal services of Greenwoods & Freehills to consider the retrospective proposals. The legal opinion provided by Greenwoods & Freehills to VACC is that, “While the Australian Taxation Office’s view is a reasonable one…it is not the only reasonable interpretation.”

Greenwoods & Freehills also provided the opinion that, “Should the matter be litigated, the approach that would ultimately be adopted by a court is not clear, or at least not as clear as the Commissioner suggests.”

“VACC is opposed to the luxury car tax on many levels. But it remains unclear as to what is so urgent or special about an increase in the LCT that the usual norms of taxation are discarded? So far Government has failed to provide consumers and car dealers with a satisfactory explanation. VACC will continue to oppose this unfair and out-dated tax,” Mr Purchase said.

POSTED BY: VICTORIAN AUTOMOTIVE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS, 28/08/2008 

HOLDEN VECTRA CDXI 2003:  RE: HOLDEN CANNOT MAKE A CAR THAT LAST 5 YEARS!     *REPLY*

28/08/2008

ISSUE:
MANY PROBLEMS

Hi I totally agree Holden can not make a car that lasts. We own a 2003 Holden Vectra CDXI and have had nothing but problems since May this year. Emission light coming on car has broken down 3 times first driving from Townsville to Sunshine Coast. Took it to Holden they told us it was the fuel pump costing us $1130. Then it broke down two weeks later and they told us it was to do with the injectors costing us $557 (ripped off I’d say). It has now broken down again. Took it back costing us $185 to look we got a second opinion and that mechanic believes a piston has blown. The car now makes a clucking noise and we have been advised not to drive it till fixed which will probably cost $2000 plus.

Not happy to have a top of the range car sitting in the drive way doing nothing.

POSTED BY: KYLIE  - SUNSHINE COAST, QLD, AUS, 28/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"HOLDEN ASTRA 2002: HOLDEN CANNOT MAKE A CAR THAT LAST 5 YEARS! - Purchased Holden Astra Jan 2002 then:-

Sept 2004 - had to replace ignition barrell, which apparently is a common fault with Astra. Luckily this one was covered by warranty.

Dec 2006 - had to replace ignition barrell, however as I was 8 weeks outside warranty for the last barrell, Holden could do nothing. Have to ring locksmith for this job, luckily I found who knew all about this fault & it only took him 1hr to fix for $165. A lot cheaper than Holden quote.

Jan 2007 - Emissions light came on, had no choice but to take to Holden. They serviced the car & told me ECU had been sorted. Whilst driving home that day the light came back on a again, now it seems it's either a Coil Pack problem or ECU again. Either way I'm looking at minimum $1000 to fix."
POSTED BY: T MCINNES - BRISBANE, QLD - AUS 26/1/2007

========== REPLY ==========
What was the end result with your car?

Please advise as I have just had coil replaced and now emissions light and traction control come on for no apparent reason. Even when I'm stationary!

The car then runs rough and just dies out. It does re-start again - wow what a bonus.

So far (other than when scanner picked up coil issue) nothing else shows up on scanner. Have been back to mechanic twice and back there again today. Dreading what he is gonna tell me this afternoon.

Did you replace the ECU? Did it fix the problem?

Please advise, any help greatly appreciated.
POSTED BY: MELISSA MACGILL - PARA HILLS, SA, AUS 17/12/1007

========== REPLY ==========
My 2001 Astra is doing the same as yours 4 days at one mechanic who then said he couldn't fix it. Took it to Holden dealer, they have had it 3 days and still have no idea."
POSTED BY: SUE - MACKAY, QLD, AUS 22 AUG 2008

========== REPLY ==========
It looks like there's a theme here...

Sue - is your problem the emissions light and traction control light coming on at the same time?

If so, I have just replaced the coil module (approx $480 plus labour). 24 hrs later, the mechanic tells me that the traction control light is coming on again shortly followed by the emissions light. He has called a computer technician to investigate further (later today) but also he has another Astra TS 2003 coming in on Friday with the same problem.

I'd be interested to see if other people are experiencing the same problems, I definitely need to take it up with Holden.

Kind Regards,
K. Williams
POSTED BY: KOSTAS WILLIAMS - MELBOURNE, VIC, AUS 27 AUG 2008

HOLDEN VECTRA CDXI 2003:  RE: EMISSION LIGHT STAYING ON, CANT START VEHICLE     *REPLY*

28/08/2008

ISSUE:
IGNITION

Hi Anne,

I also am an owner of a 2003 model Vectra CDXI and have nothing but troubles with it also since May this year. It all started when we were driving from Townsville to the Sunshine Coast. Our light came on and we broke down. We took it to get it fixed they told us it was the fuel pump costing us $1130. Then it broke down again two weeks later and they told us it was something to do with the injectors costing us $557. It has now broken dawn again so we got two opinions. The second mechanic found metal filings in the engine and he believes a piston has blown which now makes the car undrivable until it is fixed which could cost $2000 plus. Our car has only 120000 ks on the clock, not happy at all. Hope your problem isn’t as big as ours.

POSTED BY: KYLIE  - SUNSHINE COAST, QLD, AUS, 28/08/2008  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Hi I have a problem with my emissions light coming on & then my car stalling as well; it all started about 7 months ago. I have lost count of the money I have spent trying to 'solve' this problem & am very worried I am going to get smashed up the rear end one day when my car stalls. I still have no answer.

The last check I had that cost me only $150 & told me every thing was ok now said I just had to keep my fuel above the red line. Well it is now happening when the fuel gauge is at three quarters full. I have spent over $3,000 & still it stalls. Is there anyone out there who knows what this problem is with the 03 Vectra & how to fix it? As before this started happening I really loved the car I purchased it new."
POSTED BY: ANNE JOHNSON - PORT MACQUARIE, NSW, AUS 19 MAY 2008

========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"HOLDEN VECTRA 2003: EMISSION LIGHT STAYING ON, CAN'T START VEHICLE - When starting the car first up radio and dash lights up but car will not start. Then the emission light stays on while traveling. Then all of a sudden the vehicle comes to a stand still as vehicle loses all power. Vehicle has been in three (3) different Holden dealers and this problem is still going on.

Now I have lost confidence in driving long distance."
POSTED BY: ROGER PITTAWAY - BROKEN HILL, NSW, AUS 9 JAN 2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Roger,

If you have a further look on this site you will see my recent dramas regarding the emission light being on and the car conking out. This is for an Astra though. It sounds very similar to my problems though.

Initially my mechanic replaced coil, $550 then it started doing the same as yours. I got fed up and contacted dealer and end result was they just replaced EGR valve. I paid $450 for this; actual cost they quoted was around $1080. I paid less because car would have been covered under warranty BUT I didn't get my most recent service done there - so they said I wasn't covered.

My mechanic had diagnosed the EGR valve but also the throttle body motor. Holden didn't check the throttle body motor to my knowledge even though I told them about it. So far all I've done is drive it home from them (40kms) and so far so good.

However I have lost confidence in the car and will be selling it.
POSTED BY: MELISSA - , SA 11/1/2008

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Roger,

Same thing on my 3.2 Vectra CDXi manual. I got the car a month ago with the emission lit all the time whenever I drive. At first I thought it shows my engine is running so I didn’t bother. Then looked at manual and it says there's a problem with the emission and I may need to service it but still the car is driveable. What the heck ... I drove it from Melbourne Vic to Parammata NSW and back. Tested the car as much as I can and it didn’t let me down. The car never stalled at all. Honestly I am impressed with this car's easy handling in every situation I put it into. Everything seems work perfectly except the emission light which gives me a worry all the time. It feels like if I don’t fix this problem (don’t know if it’s a problem at all to me) I might get into trouble later.

I checked this problem on the internet and it tells me that this emission monitoring system is about regulating the fuel going to the engine making sure it doesn’t burn more fuel than it should be. My Vectra seems ok coz it averages 9.8 liters/100Km travelling around Melbourne East to West. Long drive averages 8.5 liters/100Km. Reach Paramatta from Clayton Vic around 80 liters of fuel for a distance of 850+ Kms.

I hope my experience and research will give you an idea what’s the problem in your car if its keeps stalling. The emission monitoring system probably detects the engine doesn’t get enough fuel or something along gas tube to engine has a leak that prevents you to get enough fuel.

I am surprised with my Vectra with its fuel consumption. I'm not sure if it’s within the normal range. If it drops further down then maybe I'll get the same problem as yours; losing power and stalls. For now I don't have any problem with it so far.

Once your car is fixed, please let me know what really went wrong with your car. If my logical approach and explanation help at all in solving your problem with the Holden mechanics.

Regards, Ezzy
POSTED BY: EZZY - CLAYTON, VIC, AUS 14/01/2008
NEXT PAGE
PREVIOUS  TOP    
LATEST POSTING
MAKES    LINKS
ADD YOUR CONTRIBUTION
© 2000-2008 COMPLAINTS CORNER - Bestcade MotorSM.com. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ® Registered Trademark of MotorSM