TERMS & CONDITIONS   CARS   TRUCKS   BIKES   CARAVANS   BOATS   MACHINES   BS LINK   MOTORSM.COM
COMPLAINTS CORNER
complaints.motorsm.com
"Complaints Corner" provides an online billboard to publicize problems or complaints about your car or poor after-sales support from dealerships and manufacturers. Good news about exceptional customer service etc. will also be published. N.B. MotorSM is not responsible nor endorse views expressed by contributors.
LATEST POSTING
LOG IN - ADD COMMENTS
JUNE 2007 - COMPLAINTS CORNER     2007: 11/07 10/07 9/07 8/07 7/07 6/06 5/07 4/07 3/07 2/07 1/07    2006

FORD FALCON BA XT 2003:  IF ENOUGH PEOPLE GET TOGETHER AND COMPLAIN    *COMPLAINT*

30/06/2007

ISSUE:
TRANSMISSION

My BA radiator ruptured & contaminated the trans fluid. Took it to Adtrans service dept who told me what the problem was & said I needed a new radiator, hoses, overflow tank, block flush, coolant & replacement trans as the coolant would have ruined the internals. Quoted $4700.

I then started researching on the net & asking people in the trade & found this has been a recognised fault with the BA. I contacted Ford customer relations & spoke to Ryan. He gave me a reference number & asked me to take it to a Ford dealer (ADRIEN BRIEN) for inspection. They told me the same story & thought Ford would fix it & said Ford would contact me.

After waiting 4 days I rang Ryan & he said they would not help. More research. Then I rang Ryan again to get a reason, but he was on the phone & I was told he would ring me back, he must be still on the phone (4 days now).

The car was serviced by Ford dealers, has done 118Km and out of warranty but because Ford had known about this fault & fixed some out of warranty they should have done a recall & rectified the problem & not just hope too many people would complain.

I would like all owners to get together & perhaps get a lawyer to represent us in our claims. Any info & advice please email me so we can get organised. Brian.

POSTED BY: BRIAN LITTLE - ADELAIDE, SA - AUS, 30/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
I have just purchased a 2003 BA XT and I am now reading about this problem with the coolant contaminating the transmission fluid.

Have Ford done anything about this problem since it happened to you?

Regards.
POSTED BY: SIMON THOMAS - WILLIAMSTOWN, VIC 8/8/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hello Brian,

We have just been reading your feedback about the BA Falcon. Today we have our Falcon being serviced and just got a call from Jarvis Ford saying that they have noticed that exact problem beginning to occur with our vehicle. The quote to fix it so far is $5,600 or $2,800 if they don't need to change the transmission. What happened with your case? I look forward to hearing from you.

Kind Regards, Dave
POSTED BY: DAVE JANZOW - ADELAIDE, SA 26/9/2007

KIA CARNIVAL  2005:  LOSING COOLANT - FIX?    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

29/06/2007

ISSUE:
COOLING SYSTEM

Yep - we have a 2005 Kia Carnival and it just keeps draining away that coolant - we started to get this erratic thumping from the engine bay when idling - its started each time after we have had a yearly "Service" (mind you at different dealerships).

The fix that was the best was from Ballina Kia (we actually made it to Ballina on Holidays). Anyway the known fault is Air in the engine that needs to be sucked out and then coolant added ... our Kia went fine until we got our second service at the new Pymble Kia. And now it literally drinks coolant!

Anyone got any ideas as it's definitely not a blown head gasket (yet).

POSTED BY: PAUL POTMA - SYDNEY, NSW - AUS, 29/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
My 2004 Pregio has just drunk all my coolant also, but has replaced it with engine oil. The head OK, gasket OK, oil cooler OK etc. It is now suspected crack within the engine itself that has very slowly become worse. Check your coolant reservoir for oil and inside the top of the radiator. I'm hoping my case is a one off and not a common complaint as I'm currently replacing the engine.
POSTED BY: GAVIN - BRISBANE, QLD 1/7/2007

HOLDEN 1 TONNER  2003:  GEARBOX BEARINGS    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

29/06/2007

ISSUE:
MANUFACTURER

Basically we purchased a 2003 Holden Rodeo LT model and had it for five months. Serviced it every 5000ks as advised from the warranty booklet. It had done around 60'000 when we bought it and we have only done 10'000 since.

We noticed the gearbox was making a rattling noise so we got it checked out and stripped only to find that two bearings were worn. We then applied for a claim through our mechanical warranty for a new set of bearings and labour costs. We were told that they don't cover wear and tear but because it was not a fair wear and tear they would pay for two bearings only and not the rest because they weren't damaged.

Our mechanic cannot guarantee the repair without a new full set of bearings which has left us with having to pay over a grand for the rest of the parts. We have been told by many mechanics that bearings usually wear out at around 400'000 or 500'000ks not at 70'000ks.

We then approached Holden asking for assistance or if it could be a manufacturing fault and they didn't want to know about anything about it. Apparently nobody seems to know how those bearings got worn out with such low kilometers which only lead us to thinks it's a fault with Holden's manufacturing. Any advice on what we could do to sort this problem out would be great thanks.

POSTED BY: PHILLIP BROWN - HASTINGS, NEW ZEALAND, 29/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK

FORD FALCON BA XT 2002:  FUEL SENDER!    *COMPLAINT*

29/06/2007

ISSUE:
PETROL

Suspect fuel sender ... thanks Ford just ran out of petrol (on a full tank!) Angry! Not good enough. Ford = found on rubbish dump!

POSTED BY: JADE WEITERING - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS, 29/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK

HOLDEN COMMODORE VY S 2004:  RE: DOOR LOCK ISSUES    *REPLY*

28/06/2007

ISSUE:
LOCKS

I own a Holden Commodore VY S and have encounted the same problem with the front passenger door. Just wondering how you got on? I am in the same situation as you. It has only done 40000 on the clock and the factory warranty expired in March. Did the CRC work or did the problem continue, if so what was the cost? Thanks

POSTED BY: MATTHEW KIDD - HAMILTON, WAIKATO, NEW ZEALAND, 28/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"Have a VY Commodore which has 48000 kms on the clock. Recently have discovered problems with the passenger rear door lock not working with the remote. I do not understand that a car which is relatively new is experiencing such problems. Unfortunately the warranty expired a few months before the trouble commenced.

Has anyone else experienced the same problem? If so what causes it and what is the cost?"
POSTED BY: J ARTIX - ADELAIDE, SA 1/03/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Can you lift it up manually? mine wouldn't let me do that either(older model), so I took the inside door panel off and sprayed the part where the rod meets the central locking mechanism (wouldn't be to different from the back door I think) with CRC and also some good grease spray. Hasn't had a problem since. Good Luck.
POSTED BY: BRAD - KALGOORLIE, WA 18/4/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Door actuator is the problem.
POSTED BY: SINCLARE - SYDNEY, NSW 30/9/2007

FORD FOCUS  2005:  FRONT DISK BRAKE ROTORS NEED REPLACING AFTER 30,000 KMS    *COMPLAINT*

28/06/2007

ISSUE:
BRAKES

Took my Ford Focus to City Ford where I bought it new for scheduled 30,000 km service. I was surprised when I was told that all the brake pads as well as the front disk rotors needed replacing.

I do not think that the disk rotors should only last 30,000 kms. The cars still has the original set of tyres on it when bought new and they are still OK. I can accept the pads can be worn out and need to be replaced but can't understand how the disk rotors can wear out earlier than the tyres. There must be something wrong with them in the first place.

The sad thing is I was not only charged for the rotors but also for labour. I believe that this problem must be covered by new vehicle warranty or the rotors should, at least, be fitted free of charge.

POSTED BY: HENRY PUYAT - SYDNEY, NSW - AUS, 28/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Henry, the only advise I can give you, (and only because our Jeep didn't even last that long) is that pads and rotors only have 12 month/ 20000 klm warranty on defective / faulty workmanship and this is despite the whole car (supposedly) have more & sometimes 3yr/100000 klm warrantees etc. This does not however cover wear & tear (worn out) but this is where its not fair. Nothing is said about the fact that your car, like mine, is designed for the European market where the aggressive nature of the pad and soft compound of the rotor means they wear at the same rate. This works quite well in Europe, just not here, but the makers are just allowed to bring them in, sell as a new car here and not change the compound to suit our driving conditions.

Do yourself a favour, next time don't put the genuine parts on. Buy aftermarket rotors (there are about 5 major manufacturers in Aust worth buying) and fit a set of Bendix pads and you will be amazed at the huge klm difference you get out of them then.

Through heaps of phone calls and searching the net I found out what I needed to know about my own problem & my mother-in-law suffered the same fate with her Focus. Its not just limited to Ford or Jeep. There are a lot of others guilty of this same problem. Just look at how many cars you see on the road with the tell tale brake dust (large amounts) on the front wheels all the time.
POSTED BY: CRAIG - SPRINGFIELD LAKES, QLD 4/7/2007

HOLDEN ASTRA CITY 2001:  ASTRA IGNITION PROBLEMS, A/C, BRAKES, EXPENSIVE PARTS    *COMPLAINT*

28/06/2007

ISSUE:
ELECTRICAL

I have had a 2001 TS Astra City with a 1.8 litre engine from new. At first it was a nice car to drive, looked good, and ran well.

First problem noisy brakes, pads replaced at 3000k. Next at 50,000k air conditioner replaced $1200. Next at 74000k ignition problems - the yellow engine icon lit on alarm panel and engine running rough. I was told the coil pack needed replacing; $720 later but symptoms soon returned. So I reasoned if you can help a home computer sometimes when it gets in a knot by powering it down and restarting it the same should apply to a car computer (ECU). So I unplugged it and plugged it back in and sure enough it corrected the problem. Also the battery had to be disconnected to get rid of the alarm. This might not always work but worth a try before you spend a heap of money.

Does the timing belt have to be replaced with both types of 1.8litre engines at 60,000k?

POSTED BY: PETER GREBERT - BRISBANE, QLD - AUS, 28/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Your question: Does the timing belt have to be replaced with both types of 1.8litre engines at 60,000k?

Answer: ABSOLUTELY!
POSTED BY: PHIL - BRISBANE, QLD 29/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
We're now up to replacing the airconditioner at 78,000. Unbelievably bad product engineering. Ours is a 2002 Astra CD. Apparently a computer is showing a fault ... perhaps could reset the computer! I'll have to try it.

Perhaps we could gang up against Holden.
POSTED BY: ANDREW W - ADELAIDE, SA 29/8/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Peter

Just reading your Astra problems from June. I just had my coil replaced but now the car is doing a similar thing - running rough and has cut out twice at traffic lights.

Are you mechanically minded? How do you unplug the computer in an attempt to fix the problem? Can any lay person do it?

Holden told me that because my mechanic was not a Holden dealer maybe he hadn't re-set the computer properly.

I don't know how much is Holden just spinning scare tactics and how much is the truth
POSTED BY: MELISSA - PARA HILLS, SA 13/12/2007

NISSAN PATROL TI 2002:  RE: WRONG DIFFERENTIAL     *REPLY*

28/06/2007

ISSUE:
DIFFERENTIAL

Douglas,

I too own a 2001/2002 Nissan Patrol Ti 4800, original owner. I have noticed more recently the problem of the tyre wearing out very quickly on the left hand side also. I too tried to have wheel alignments done, but to very little improvements.

The tyre mob actually did tell me to take it to a suspension specialist. To date I have not been able to get there. Where did you end up taking your vehicle to and what was the part called that was required to fix this problem? And finally did the problem go away?

Appreciate your response, Vince...

POSTED BY: VINCE AZZOPARDI - BLACKTOWN, NSW - AUS, 28/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"In March 2002, we bought a new 4.2 Turbo Nissan Patrol Diesel Wagon with a limited slip diff. We have since travelled 100,000kms. It would have done less than 100 kms in 4WD and possibly 12,000 kms pulling a caravan. I do most of the servicing myself, as I have had 4x4 for 40 years and had always done the servicing.

When changing the rear diff oil I noticed small metal pieces. The metal pieces were the limited slip rings, which had broken up for some reason. There was no noise or damage to the crown wheel pinion. When I took the diff to the diff and transmission people, they informed me that it appeared that I had a pre 97 diff or an Y60 instead of an Y61. The difference between the two diffs is a massive increase in the size of the limited slip part in the Y61. On further investigation and inquiry at the Nissan dealership spare parts, I found this to be the truth.

I presented all this information to the customer relations people in Melbourne, who assured me that this just could not happen, despite of having it photographed and identified by the dealership. Later when I requested to see the Nissan Company rep I was told that if Melbourne told me there was nothing further they could do then the rep couldn’t help me.

Most Nissan Patrols also have a fault with the left hand front wheel, which will scrub out the tyre. A steering alignment cannot fix this. It has to have a part (not Nissan) that is readily available and which realigns the top bearing in the swivel pin housing.

Also, if you are a 4.2 Turbo owner and you want considerably more power, all you have to do is put a 3 inch muffler system from the turbo onwards, then have a diesel specialist do the timing and you will have a different vehicle."
POSTED BY: DOUGLAS MCGILCHRIST - WALLABADAH, NSW 26/06/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Try www.truckalign.com.au . They have been around for years manufacturing parts that stop tyres from scrubbing out.
Good Luck, Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC 30/6/2007

NISSAN NAVARA 3.0DX 2003:  PROBLEM WITH INJECTORS / INJECTOR PUMP    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

27/06/2007

ISSUE:
REPAIR

I have a 2003 Navara, 3.0lt, dual cab diesel. I have recently struck a "surging" problem, that only happens "under load", e.g. 3000RPM+. It only happens in 3rd & 4th gears and no others. I have run injector cleaner through it, twice. I have also had it on the freeway, 4th & 5th gear, up to 190km/hr, and no problems reaching & maintaining speed.

Mechanic has told me "could be injectors, which we'd have to replace (at $300 each), or injector pump ($2500 min)". Has run diagnostics, and still not sure. Hit & hope method, I've been told. Start by replacing one injector at a time & hope. After that, injector pump for sure! Anyone had this problem before, or knows how to repair or what I should be looking for?

POSTED BY: MATT LEWIS - MELBOURNE, VIC - AUS, 27/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Try the Mass air flow sensor. the Patrols with the same engine have this same symptom and it is usually the fault.
POSTED BY: ANDREW - SYDNEY, NSW 27/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
I was talking to the Foreman at Main North Nissan in Adelaide and he mentioned that they were having a lot of problems with the 3.0L Diesels, mainly when bio diesel was used in them. He mentioned repairs requiring removal of the head. Have you been using bio diesel? If not it may still pay to give them a ring and find out if they can help as I am sure they have had a lot of experience with your model. Would be interested to find out if you have any luck.
Cheers; David.
POSTED BY: DAVID - MOUNT BARKER, SA 27/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Give AG Diesels in Springvale a call. They are diesel specialists with an excellent reputation.
Good Luck, Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC 30/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
I have had experience with a similar fault on Navara's. There are a series of 'valves/sensors' on the gearbox which are used to reduce engine power in certain gears (reverse, 1st and 2nd I think). If one of these is playing up/sticking when you are in the 3rd/4th gate it will cause erratic switching between full power and reduced power settings that may feel like 'hunting'.

This fault will not be logged by the ECU and will explain why you don't have a fault in 1st/2nd gate or in 5th. Have them checked out (Removed and checked). I have seen people spend thousands of dollars on the fuel system only to need a simple valve/sensor replaced.

Hope this helps, Neal.
POSTED BY: NEAL - EMERALD, QLD 6/08/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Matt
I have a GL Patrol 3L turbo which is probably the same motor. I also have a problem where I lose power over 3000 revs generally when pulling hard or over taking. When I take the foot off the accelerator the engine jumps back into life under power. The problem is that it’s intermittent and we just recently did 11000klms trip to Cape York.

The car performed really well with 4 people and a load of supplies. Along the way these little power losses came in patches. I think the problem is fuel, not water which is where I started (because I bleed for water a couple of times and there was none in the filter). I think it may have something to do with the bio additives, reason it only happened with certain tank fulls and others never murmured. I heard on radio today that Caltex I think are trialing a vortex diesel which will probably be much better controlled in manufacture. I think I will give that a try. Let me know if you get any advancement. Cheers
POSTED BY: JOHN SANDILANT - SYDNEY, NSW 19/8/2007

NISSAN PATHFINDER  2006:  COOL AIR BEING SENT TO THE FEET     *FEEDBACK WANTED*

27/06/2007

ISSUE:
AIR CONDITIONER

Cool Air being sent to the feet when the all the dials are turned off.

POSTED BY: ARTHUR WILLEMSE - BRISBANE, QLD - AUS, 27/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK

RENAULT SCENIC RX4  0:  RE: PROBLEMS     *REPLY*

26/06/2007

ISSUE:
BRAKES

Hello to everyone out there who has been unfortunate enough to have bought Renault Scenic 4x4! This vehicle is an out and out death trap ...

We were just about to go driving in Mpumalanga. The afternoon before we left we were driving along and all of a sudden we had No Brakes! Imagine driving on the mountain routes in Mpumalanga and finding you have no clutch and no brakes. The garage who sold us this second hand vehicle sent it to Renault 4 times to have it fixed.

1st, 2nd and 3rd times it came back, we were told it had been fixed ... wrong same old problem week after week! The last time it went to Renault I called the head office and had to get quite angry in order to get anything done. Finally they seemed to have fixed it. But my question is for how long. When I am going to be driving along and suddenly find I have no brakes again ... Why do Renault allow this to happen? They obviously are aware that this car has a major defect!

Has anyone had this problem fixed and then go on to develop the same problem again and again? We all need to come to together and make Renault fix their faulty and dangerous cars. They will just keep on dismissing individuals because they can, but if we all act together and make a big noise and bring it to the attention of media in our various countries and shame Renault into doing what they should. Please! Before Someone Dies As A Direct Result Of This.

POSTED BY: NAOMI  - JOBURG, SOUTH AFRICA, 26/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"Has anyone had problems with Renault RX4 differential or transfer box"
POSTED BY: WAYNE PREECE - LICHTENBURG, SOUTH AFRICA 19/04/2007

========== REPLY ==========
I would love to get contact numbers of all Renault RX4 owners or past owners as I am extremely distressed about my vehicle and the way I am being treated by Renault Northcliff, especially Morne the service manager.
Took my car in for 60 000km service and from then it was a downward spiral. First the engine mountings breaking and asked to pay for the damage which I have subsequently found out is a regular occurrence! The petrol cap broke off at 40000km, then while driving in a deserted farm area with my 2 young boys the prop shaft / differential fell out! This car is Unsafe and Renault should remove them from the market totally knowing that this is a problem.

I randomly called dealers asking them about the car and they said "Dont Buy Problems With Differential/Propshaft, bad history, expensive after 70000km they are not reliable"! I hired AA to inspect the car only to find that they pushed the propshaft back into place! They blamed the tow company who has denied it So What Are They Hiding! I have several witnesses to verify that the propshaft dropped.
Morne's attitude is you have to pay R25000 otherwise come and tow your car away. The worst of it all is that they sold me an extended warranty and apparently it is not a reliable one on top of it ... not worth the paper it is written on.

I too had brake failure but was brief, not re-occurred but it was a concern as I just recently replaced my brakes. It just continues. I am fighting Renault and therefore need assistance to fight this case. Please contact me via email, I would love to chat to you. Thanks
POSTED BY: RENEE WRIGHT - NORTHCLIFF, SOUTH AFRICA 26/7/2007

KIA CARNIVAL  2006:  STEERING PULLS TO LEFT BADLY ON SHORT WHEEL BASE CARNIVAL    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

26/06/2007

ISSUE:
STEERING

My wife purchased this vehicle. It pulls badly to left hand side. Has anyone had the same problem? And what was done to rectify it?

POSTED BY: TONY NANOS - SOMERVILLE, VIC - AUS, 26/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Hi there, I have the very same problem. Please contact me on the e-mail for further discussion.
POSTED BY: ROGER - MINCHINBURY, NSW 3/7/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi, yes my Carnival did pull to the left slightly, but the dealer I bought it off contacted me and told me that it was a known problem (to dealers that is) and Kia had advised dealers to check Carnivals made before I think it was October or November 06 for the alignment of the strut springs on the front. Having had this done has seemed to fix the pulling to left but I still feel that the tyres are wearing excessively even after having a wheel alignment done.

Has anyone experienced excessive tyre wear?"
POSTED BY: IAN BORGER - FREDERICKTON, NSW 8/07/2007

NISSAN NAVARA STR 2004:  NISSAN NAVARA STR    *COMPLAINT*

26/06/2007

ISSUE:
4X4

Well here we go - I purchased my Navara brand spanker from Toowoomba Qld. It was that new it was still on boat when I ordered it. So after waiting several weeks the day comes to pick her up.

I get to dealership and was told come back later as it was not ready so I go away and come back later - still not ready. Then after another hour and half they bring her out. Well there were scuff marks and grease from the shipping all over it. They said that they are easily removed so I agreed to take it only because I have been waiting so long for the ****** thing.

Well I get her home and notice bullbar is bent yep bent that it had a crease underneath it. On closer inspection one of the blinker wires on the bullbar were also broken so back to dealer I go. They say I been paddock bashing in it (40,000 dollar paddock basher yer right) so they refuse to fix it. So I had to get blinker fix myself; bulbar still same.

Secondly I used to tow a tinny on. Going fishing one day I was reversing down boat ramp and the windscreen cracked from one side to the other. So I contact dealer again and they said it was my own fault and they did not want to look at it.

Now as I was working on a property I was travelling along a dirt road for 15 km to get to town. I notice that dust was getting sucked inside of it from around all the doors. So I contact dealer again but was a bit more ****** off at them this time. So they finally had a look at it. When I go and pick it up they told me that this was normal as it was not intended for driving along dirt roads (this is a 4wd Nissan Navara) and they also said that no car is air tight. Well maybe not it still should not suck in the amount of dust it was. What is the use of having 4wd if you can't use it?

There have been other minor problems with it but got sick of Nissan stuffing me around and fixed myself. Until now it starts raining (this is why I writing this) and there is water leaking in on driver side that much I can scoop it out by the hands full. Well car is just out of warranty so I go to see the local dealer, and they say to me at service - are my feet getting wet from the water leaking that is how bright they are. Anyway they ask how old it was and I said 3 years old and then she goes on and says that behind the dash could be rusted out. I said the ****** thing is only three years old and it better not be rusted out or I will get very ******.

So she goes out back and another girl comes out and says the same thing. That it might be rusted out so I tell her for Nissans sake it better not at three years old. So she said I had to book it in so they can yet have another look at it but not until next week (when the rain stops I suppose) so I won't find out until then if I got a court case on my hand or not ... Let hope not.

So when buying from Nissan, people do your homework. Other than that the Navara drives great. Put it through every trick you know of before you buy and get your services from your own mechanic you trust - Nissan are just too dear for these. Cheers and good luck.

POSTED BY: CHRIS STALLAN - NOOSA, QLD - AUS, 26/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Sorry you have had troubles. I can only say that I am completely satisfied with both my Navara and the dealer.

Servicing ... I have this done by the same small business, Nissan are too expensive for what they do.

My dilemma at the moment is that I want to buy a Slide On Camper. Nissan don't have anything with a space cab ute and flat tray ... maybe the new Patrol with the 3 Litre Diesel may be the answer .Otherwise I am leaning towards a Holden Rodeo.
POSTED BY: PETER OGBORNE - ALBANY, WA 2/7/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Yeah we hear lots of Navara problems in Moree with dust and water leaking. My suggestion would be next time spend the extra money on a Hilux. My latest model Hilux has done 25,000 klms through Moree dust mainly dirt roads and it does not leak in any dust OR water. The only suggestion would be to run your a/c on high when driving on dusty roads.
POSTED BY: RICHARD - MOREE, NSW 23/9/2007

NISSAN PATROL  2002:  WRONG DIFFERENTIAL    *COMPLAINT*

26/06/2007

ISSUE:
DIFFERENTIAL

In March 2002, we bought a new 4.2 Turbo Nissan Patrol Diesel Wagon with a limited slip diff. We have since travelled 100,000kms. It would have done less than 100 kms in 4WD and possibly 12,000 kms pulling a caravan. I do most of the servicing myself, as I have had 4x4 for 40 years and had always done the servicing.

When changing the rear diff oil I noticed small metal pieces. The metal pieces were the limited slip rings, which had broken up for some reason. There was no noise or damage to the crown wheel pinion. When I took the diff to the diff and transmission people, they informed me that it appeared that I had a pre 97 diff or an Y60 instead of an Y61. The difference between the two diffs is a massive increase in the size of the limited slip part in the Y61. On further investigation and inquiry at the Nissan dealership spare parts, I found this to be the truth.

I presented all this information to the customer relations people in Melbourne, who assured me that this just could not happen, despite of having it photographed and identified by the dealership. Later when I requested to see the Nissan Company rep I was told that if Melbourne told me there was nothing further they could do then the rep couldn’t help me.

Most Nissan Patrols also have a fault with the left hand front wheel, which will scrub out the tyre. A steering alignment cannot fix this. It has to have a part (not Nissan) that is readily available and which realigns the top bearing in the swivel pin housing.

Also, if you are a 4.2 Turbo owner and you want considerably more power, all you have to do is put a 3 inch muffler system from the turbo onwards, then have a diesel specialist do the timing and you will have a different vehicle.

POSTED BY: DOUGLAS MCGILCHRIST - WALLABADAH, NSW - AUS, 26/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Douglas,
I too own a 2001/2002 Nissan Patrol Ti 4800, original owner. I have noticed more recently the problem of the tyre wearing out very quickly on the left hand side also. I too tried to have wheel alignments done, but to very little improvements.

The tyre mob actually did tell me to take it to a suspension specialist. To date I have not been able to get there. Where did you end up taking your vehicle to and what was the part called that was required to fix this problem? And finally did the problem go away?

Appreciate your response, Vince...
POSTED BY: VINCE AZZOPARDI - BLACKTOWN, NSW 28/6/2007

HOLDEN COMMODORE VX SS 2001:  CAR HESITATES ON OPEN ROAD ANY SPEED ANY GEAR LIKE A MISS HELP!    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

25/06/2007

ISSUE:
ENGINE

I have VX SS Series 1 - problem comes and goes and is like a hesitation or a miss but only happens every now and again. Car only has 50,000kms.

Anyone have any ideas? I have taken it to two dealerships and they have been no help.

POSTED BY: BRADLEY OBRIEN - MUSWELLBROOK, NSW - AUS, 25/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
So long as the dealer has checked for codes, maybe a spark plug or HT lead. Or maybe vacuum leak or exhaust leak. I suggest you take it for a proper diagnosis to Newcastle City Holden and talk to Andrew, he is very good.
POSTED BY: L J - NEWCASTLE, NSW 27/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Maybe sparkplug or vacuum leak. There is a vacuum pipe that’s is located near the throttle body that runs along the side of the injectors and is connected to another at the back, driver’s side.
POSTED BY: SINCLARE - SYDNEY, NSW 30/9/2007

========== REPLY ==========
To me it sound like spark plug needs replacing, or leads, but the most common problem of those models is the vacuum leak beside the throttle body that runs along the back of the motor that hose needs to be changed but first check it out.
POSTED BY: NAME, LOCATION NOT SUPPLIED 30/9/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Hi Bradley,

Not sure if this issue has been sorted for you yet. I am still awaiting membership approval to this site that’s why I am contacting you this way.

I had a similar issue with my SS. I too and so did the Holden service foreman think it was a plug problem. The issue was caused by the Mass Air Flow sensor, it’s the metal part located between the air box (filter) on its way to the throttle body. At the bottom of the sensor is a small electrical part. If water or moisture gets into it, it will cause the car to hesitate while driving to the point, its like the car has a server engine miss.

Regards, Phil
POSTED BY: PHIL HEGGARTY - CANBERRA, ACT 4/10/2007

TOYOTA COROLLA ASCENT 2003:  ACCELERATOR STICKING ON AT 100-105 KPH AND BRAKES CEASE UP    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

25/06/2007

ISSUE:
MISCELLANEOUS

Has anyone had any trouble with their accelerator sticking on at high speed? This happens every now and then about 6-8 weeks intervals. When I try to apply the brake it is like trying to push down on a brick.
Graham. Caringbah

POSTED BY: KAY TRAPPETT - MILPERRA, NSW - AUS, 25/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
My sister was at a red light last week. As she pressed on the accelerator the car acted as if it was in a race causing the car to do 3 360 turns and when she went to hit the brakes the car locked up then died on her. The whole system shut down.

Toyota came and towed the car at their expense, and said that her computer had malfunctioned. She went to the hospital and has severe whiplash, major consistent headache since as well as numbness in her arm.

Yes she has got a lawyer especially after they had documented it was a malfunction on behalf of her car and through no fault of her own.

She bought her Corolla brand new last year.

Heather
POSTED BY: HEATHER - DERRY, NH USA 19/9/2007

MAZDA B2600  1998:  WENT THROUGH 2 MANUAL GEARBOXES IN 380K    *COMPLAINT*

25/06/2007

ISSUE:
TRANSMISSION

Sorry to bring on more depressing news guys but Mazda Bravo/Ford courier gearboxes are ****. Transmission shops will tell you to expect 130 to 200k out of manuals 4x4s and in my case 4x2. My first box cost me 3000k 3 years ago, my second box let go 2 months ago so I rebuilt it myself for $920 in parts.

The good news is the motors petrol and diesel are excellent, mine being petrol on gas with 399k and still going strong.

POSTED BY: BEN TAYLOR - PERTH, WA - AUS, 25/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK

MITSUBISHI LANCER CH/ES 2004:  MITSUBISHI 2004 POSSIBLE NOISE FROM BRAKES!    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

24/06/2007

ISSUE:
BRAKES

I am only concerned since I purchased my vehicle through an auction that having my car for a little over a year that I needed to replace the brakes. As my mechanic said that the front brake pads needed replacing and so I complied. But not long after I still keep hearing a noise I think coming from the front brakes.

I've taken the car back at least three times to my mechanic and he said that they are fine and that perhaps it could be that they have dirt in them. He did clean them and even after awhile the noise came back. Then I took them back in which he said that they were fine and if I wanted to bring the car back that he would change them if I was that concerned.

I do trust my mechanic being a family friend for over 10 yrs so I have no question in his judgment. But I am about to take the car down to Sydney and would like to know if someone else has had similar complaints in regards to possible noise from brakes!
Thanks!

POSTED BY: TRISH MORROW - BRISBANE, QLD - AUS, 24/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
1. Has the disc rotors been machined? If not the glazing surface on your rotor will cause to swill or grinding sound come your brakes.
2. Use a good set of brake pads (Bendix brand) or cheap set (R.D.A, Protex, Cortec).
POSTED BY: SAM - PERTH, WA 25/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Did he machine the rotors? If not this is probably the reason you have brake squeal. If he did but used cheap pads it is another reason. I only use Bendix pads and have no problems - ask him? Otherwise the squeal is probably harmless.
POSTED BY: DEREK - CAIRNS, QLD 26/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
I have a noise coming from the front wheel/ brake area. I am having my struts replaced tomorrow, as mechanics are doing bit by bit to find what noise is ... as they are unsure too. They are trying to say it is rattling to save themselves warranty work. My problem I think is more suspension than brakes, which may be different from what you have.
POSTED BY: MEL - SUSSEX INLET, NSW 27/11/2007

FORD FALCON  1996:  RE: FORD FALCON AND HEAD GASKETS     *REPLY*

24/06/2007

ISSUE:
ENGINE

Hi Janine.
Water coming from your exhaust is not necessarily a blown (or cracked) head or gasket. The water may be condensation. Coolant from the exhaust would also be associated with a severe misfire or roughness in the motor. If you are using coolant the exhaust would also have a sickly sweet smell to it. As you have not mentioned a concern in these areas I would suggest having the cooling system pressure tested for leaks elsewhere.
Usually a leaking head gasket from the model you have would show stains on the RH side of the block or a roughness in the motor. Check for leaks, particular attention to the water pump and the pipe behind it that runs along the RH side of the motor. Sometimes these leaks are small enough to dissipate before forming a drip on the ground. I have also found that many water pumps only leak when hot and the motor is actually running. Hope this helps with your decision.

Yes EFs and ELs to tend to have more issues in this area than other models. Remember to keep the coolant (not just water) level at around 30% or more but not above 50%.

-----------------------------------------------
A footnote to my last post:

I replaced my EDs head gasket due to a coolant seepage at 170,00km. The motor still had the manufacturers hone marks in the bore (very little wear). It has now done more than 270,000km, mainly on LPG.

POSTED BY: L DAVIS - BOMADERRY, NSW - AUS, 24/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"How do you know if they is a problem with my head gaskets EF 1996 Ford?

*there is water coming out of the muffler
*I need to keep refilling the water

If they is a problem with my head gaskets is it worth fixing it, or should I buy a new engine?

Please help "
POSTED BY: JANINE PRICE - DEAN PARK, NSW 13/06/2007

========== REPLY ==========
The Ford 6 cylinder engine is VERY prone to blowing head gasket, cracking heads. It is usually caused by ... blocked radiator, broken thermostat, incorrect coolant. How many kms has your engine done? for the sake of around 1 thousand dollars you can have your car up and running again, they are very easy to do, but you will need to find out what caused the gasket/head to go in the first place. I recommend a radiator cleanout, new head bolts, reconditioned cylinder head, an AU steel head gasket, correct coolant, oil change, new thermostat. I hope that helps.
POSTED BY: STEVE - MELB, VIC 14/6/2007

HOLDEN ASTRA  1999:  RE: BE CAREFUL WITH YOUR KEYS!     *ADVICE*

24/06/2007

ISSUE:
IMMOBILIZER

Hi Shannyn.
Along the same lines as your concern. A reminder to people with more than one car with transponder (microchip) type keys. Avoid keeping the keys on the one key ring, as this can sometimes cause the receiver system to pick up multiple or mixed signals. The result can be anything from a failure to start on that attempt, to immobilization of the system. The receiver range is "very" small, so most of the time this is not an issue.

Also when using the key ensure other keys are hanging from the keyring and not beside the ignition key, as this can sometimes "mask" the transponders signal.

POSTED BY: L DAVIS - BOMADERRY, NSW - AUS, 24/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"This is so embarrassing, but I want to warn others against making the same stupid mistake I did!

My 1999 Astra has been reasonably trouble-free until yesterday, when it just wouldn't start. I knew it wasn't a flat battery - the engine would start but shut down after about 5-10 seconds. Being a woman with no idea I called NRMA, who arrived in 15mins (record time?!). This guy tried everything he could think of and was eventually convinced that it had something to do with the power-steering pump. So off goes my car - towed to the nearest Holden Dealership - with me spending the rest of the day stressing about how much this is going to cost me... I've heard anything to do with power-steering can be expensive...

Anyway, I got the call from Holden and how embarrassing. The immobiliser chip was missing from my key. I'd totally forgotten about how I'd dropped my key the night before and it had fallen apart - I had simply picked it up and clipped it back together - how was I to know the immobiliser chip had fallen out! So, red-faced and $170 later I was driving my Astra home... hahaha how embarrassing :)

The moral of the story... if your car doesn't start, try your spare key! "
POSTED BY: SHANNYN - PENRITH, NSW 14/06/2007

========== REPLY ==========
lol - thanks for being so honest...
POSTED BY: PHIL - BRISSIE, QLD 15/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
I heard of a funny story, I think it was from the UK, where a baby swallowed the key chip and the owner had to hold the baby near the ignition switch to start the car!
POSTED BY: JL - SYDNEY, NSW 22/6/2007

MITSUBISHI MAGNA TR 1993:  PUCHASED FROM AUTO GALLERY WANGARRA, COST 1800, MECH REPAIRS 2500+    *COMPLAINT*

22/06/2007

ISSUE:
DEALER - USED CAR

I bought what was supposed to be a reliable second car from "Auto Gallery" 11 Uppill Place in Wangarra WA for $1800.

During the second week I needed to replace the ignition module, leads and distributer and cap for just over $300, followed a week later with Power steering repairs for $280. This week (after a whole 5 weeks) the transmission has failed and I have a rough estimate of 2500+ to rebuild? Is it worth it?

POSTED BY: JESS JESSEP - PERTH , WA - AUS, 22/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
You bought a 14 year old car for $1800 ... obviously without getting it checked ... what do you expect?
POSTED BY: GRAHAM - SYDNEY, NSW 26/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Is it worth spending $2500 on a car worth 1800? You do the math ...
Mate give the car to the mechanic fixing the car as payment for the diagnosis. I am sure he can put the car to good use the next time monster trucks are in town.
POSTED BY: ADAM - SYDNEY, NSW 31/10/2007

HOLDEN COMMODORE  2003:  CAR STINKS OF GAS - IS THIS NORMAL?     *FEEDBACK WANTED*

22/06/2007

ISSUE:
GAS

I had a gas conversion two months ago and have had to take it back twice now to the company who changed it over as the smell inside the car was sickening. It seemed to improve then it came back again. Took it in yesterday yet again and lo and behold the smell is as bad as ever especially when waiting at lights etc.

They say they can't do anything else, that they have fixed the problem. What can I do next or is it normal to have a gas smell in the car?

Thanks for any advice.

POSTED BY: NONA PARKER - BRISBANE, QLD - AUS, 22/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
Hi Nona.
There most certainly should not be any smell of unburnt LPG at all from the system. This is definitely not normal. There may however be a slight smell of burnt LPG from the exhaust.

I suggest to check the boot of the car for any leaks, boot seal, drain grommet loose/missing or damaged vents in the boot. If however the smell is unburnt LPG, I suggest to make up a soapy water mix in a squirt bottle and spray any fittings related to the system, looking for bubbles.

While repairs can only be carried out by an appropriately authorised LPG installer/repairer you or a friend can check for leaks and report them to a repairer.
POSTED BY: L DAVIS - BOMADERRY, NSW 24/6/2007

HOLDEN ASTRA CD 1999:  RE: BE CAREFUL WITH YOUR KEYS!     *REPLY*

22/06/2007

ISSUE:
IMMOBILIZER

I heard of a funny story, I think it was from the UK, where a baby swallowed the key chip and the owner had to hold the baby near the ignition switch to start the car!

POSTED BY: J L - SYDNEY, NSW - AUS, 22/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"This is so embarrassing, but I want to warn others against making the same stupid mistake I did!

My 1999 Astra has been reasonably trouble-free until yesterday, when it just wouldn't start. I knew it wasn't a flat battery - the engine would start but shut down after about 5-10 seconds. Being a woman with no idea I called NRMA, who arrived in 15mins (record time?!). This guy tried everything he could think of and was eventually convinced that it had something to do with the power-steering pump. So off goes my car - towed to the nearest Holden Dealership - with me spending the rest of the day stressing about how much this is going to cost me... I've heard anything to do with power-steering can be expensive...

Anyway, I got the call from Holden and how embarrassing. The immobiliser chip was missing from my key. I'd totally forgotten about how I'd dropped my key the night before and it had fallen apart - I had simply picked it up and clipped it back together - how was I to know the immobiliser chip had fallen out! So, red-faced and $170 later I was driving my Astra home... hahaha how embarrassing :)

The moral of the story... if your car doesn't start, try your spare key! "
POSTED BY: SHANNYN - PENRITH, NSW 14/06/2007

========== REPLY ==========
lol - thanks for being so honest...
POSTED BY: PHIL - BRISSIE, QLD 15/6/2007

NISSAN X-TRAIL 2.5 MANUAL 2004:  FUEL PROBLEM    *FEEDBACK WANTED*

21/06/2007

ISSUE:
ENGINE

On recent trip from Adelaide to Alice, power dropped off and then suddenly surged. Did this several times until vehicle finally stopped. Waited 5 minutes vehicle went OK until 10 km out of town did the same thing again.

There is no pattern to it as it occurs now and again or several times on a trip. Whether towing requiring extra fuel demand or a normal trip the problem comes and goes. Nothing shows on the diagnostic machine.

Had 100,000 km service done in Townsville and the computer showed no fault. Returned from Townsville no problem all the way back to Alice. Recently went on a 75 km trip, took me 2 1/2 hours stop start.

Fuel filter has been changed, new plugs. Thought it could be 02 sensor which was disconnected and vehicle ran OK. Local agent says NO. Could be solenoid that controls butterfly, getting replacement.

Did 80 km run with diagnostic machine attached. Vehicle ran perfectly. Nobody seems to know what the problem is.

Any takers?

POSTED BY: BILL MITCHELL - ALICE SPRINGS, NT - AUS, 21/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== REPLY ==========
It may not be a fuel problem but might have the symptoms of one. The X-Trails have a problem with their catalytic converters and it seems some have been replaced under warranty or by goodwill from Nissan. Has yours been replaced? If the catalytic converter has a piece in it that blocks the exhaust gasses from escaping, this could be your problem.
Good Luck, Mark.
POSTED BY: MARK KURAN - MELBOURNE, VIC 30/6/2007

========== REPLY ==========
They also had problems with cam angle sensor. So get it checked out, cheers.
POSTED BY: DEREK - CAIRNS, QLD 15/7/2007

PEUGEOT 307 HDI 2006:  RE: 307 DIESEL, THINKING OF PURCHASING     *REPLY*

21/06/2007

ISSUE:
CAR BUYING

Hi, don't buy Ever a French car with HDI engines. Apart from the problems with the petrol ones, the diesels are all worthless lumps of **** metal. They are riddled with problems. The EGR valves clog up easily, thus causing Anti Pollution Fault. Let the garage fob you off and reset it, and after about a year your turbocharger goes.

My car's 378000 miles 4 years old bought from Wilsons of Epsom (steer clear from them too, email me and I'll tell you another horrendous story). Turbos died, aircon faulty, clutch fault (since 6500 miles old), wing mirrors not folding in, central locking unlocking for no reason (real good security ... not), suspension gone ... Phew, seems everyone on www.crushmy307.co.uk is having same problems. My war continues, but I have their hire car, and they're not getting it back until I get a full refund - simple!

Dont Buy French, check out www.peugeotsucks.co.uk - www.crushmy307.co.uk

POSTED BY: MARTIN  - SURREY, UNITED KINGDOM, 21/06/2007  PROVIDE FEEDBACK
========== ORIGINAL POSTING ==========
"PEUGEOT 307 DIESEL 2006: THINKING OF PURCHASING - Hi my name is Kerry, I am thinking of buying a 2006 Peugeot 307 hatch/touring XSE HDi 2.0 auto. I was wondering if anyone out there has one and knows of any problems associated with the car itself, dealerships and service centres. I do not wish to buy a lemon if possible. I currently drive a Freelander 2001 V6 auto with 173,000 klms on it, have had a few problems with it, and now think maybe it is time to trade it in and buy something different.

Maybe someone can suggest what make of cars are the most reliable. Hope to hear from you."
POSTED BY: KERRY THORNE - LAKE HAVEN, NSW 6/05/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Dear Kerry, everybody will have an opinion and they will all probably be different! So I'll give my 10c worth. The Pug is ok BUT the new ones don't ride and feel as good as the older ones on which their reputation was made. The suspension has lost the supple feel. Shame. Also there is a host of electronics that can definitely irritate. One I know of loses the plot on corrugations because the car thinks it's about to crash. The fuel economy is great but the Pug can be very expensive to fix.

As a replacement for your Freelander I would be looking at a Subaru. If your looking for a secondhand one get one away from the coast and someone to have a really good look at it. The Liberty is the bigger version then there is the Forester which is slightly smaller (and others). You will be pleasantly surprised by the reliability and the versatility. Good Luck! "
POSTED BY: JOHN AUSTIN - NARRANDERA, NSW 6/05/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Buy a Mazda "3" and get off this merry go round of rubbish.
Read a few postings and then some more between the lines.
If you want a sporty feel buy a SP.
POSTED BY: GARY V - MELBOURNE, VIC 6/05/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Don't be put off by ideas of expensive parts and service for Peugeots. It is not true. I have owned 6 and will continue to buy them. My diesel 504 has been the cheapest car to own that I have ever experienced. Peugeots are clearly better performers as manuals rather than autos. If you are looking for specific problems try the numerous Peugeot websites. A good one to start with is www.pccv.org/ and follow the links.
POSTED BY: DAVID LOFTUS - MELBOURNE, VIC 7/05/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Be aware that like some other European cars (Citroen, Alfa Romeo) Peugeot make their disc brake rotors out of recycled baked bean cans or similar. Have just had a $900 bill on 307 Estate at 38k for new rotors (front) pads are r still good. Seems like reverse logic engineering or maybe just bad engineering.
POSTED BY: BLAKE THOMPSON - SYDNEY, NSW 7/05/2007

========== REPLY ==========
Kerry, Do not buy a 307. We have one that has been an ongoing problem. It will be going back to Regan motors tomorrow for the fourth time with a catalytic problem which they can not fix. The on board computer tells them that it's been misfiring but they can not fix it. It was last in on Friday, and on Saturday, same problem. Their response is to re set the computer, and change the spark plugs.

We will be persistent, but if any other owners read this and can assist, please do so. Thanks. Russ"
POSTED BY: RUSSELL SPENCE - PRESTON, VIC 27/05/2007
NEXT PAGE
PREVIOUS  TOP    MAKE
LATEST POSTING
INDEX    MAKES    LINKS
ADD YOUR CONTRIBUTION
© 2000-2007 COMPLAINTS CORNER - MotorSM.com. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ® Registered Trademark of MotorSM P/L